HPA

Scale Free Flight Forum => FAC Free Flight Scale => Topic started by: Konrad on May 07, 2026, 01:05 AM

Title: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on May 07, 2026, 01:05 AM
This Zero is being used to reintroduce my brother to the dynamic art of flying models. He is an accomplished modeler building exquisite static scale models. He often adds details that only god can see.

Here we choose the Dumas Zero because it is laser cut, low wing, short nosed and has a tapered wing. Other than the laser cutting all these add up to a difficult model to fly.  It will force me to use all the tricks I know to get this project to fly. I feel this will make a great model to expose a person to flying models assuming they have supervision. To be sure it would make a horrible model to teach oneself!

First was to sand off the laser char. I think this char often detracts from any light finish. (This was to be a green camouflage finish. More on that later).

The next trick that never seems to be mentioned in the manuals is to pre-twist the wing saddles. This is in my opinion critical particularly with designs with such radical changes  in the fuselage to wing junction.  We heated the saddles in a microwave oven for about 15seconds after wetting the saddles with water. While the saddles were still hot twisted the saddles to the shape we expected they would need to be. 

While the saddles cooled we thinned the keels and the ID of the formers aft of the CG to be about 1/2 to a 1/3 the as cut size. We built the fuselage per the plans with the keels only using Titebond glue. We forced dried this in the microwave to drive off the moisture. With the formers in place and supported on the keels we placed the pre-shaped saddles on the formers. Using tape (not pins) we again forced dried the glue in the microwave

With the weight credits from thinning  of the keels and formers we  added some filler to support the rear mounting of the canopy.

As the Zero is a very short nosed aircraft and the Dumas Zero has an enlarged stabilizer we added nose weight in the way of balsa filler.

This is only the second or third model I've covered in Esaki tissue. Wow, what a game changer! It is much like what covering with wet silkspan is to covering in dry domestic tissue. It really is nice to use the properties of the material to the fullest.  With wet Esaki we were able to cover the bottom of this compound curved fuselage from center keel to side keel in one piece.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on May 07, 2026, 05:10 AM
Some of you might have noticed that I'm doing this old school with nitrate dope. I didn't want to add to the learning curve my ignorance on covering with the "New" water based adhesives and sealants such as those from Deluxe Material.

I'm really impressed with the quality of the covering job my brother did. While I did about 60% of the covering on this model (demonstrating the tecniques) he did the same process on the other half of the model. I can say that I can't tell which piece he applied verses the pieces I applied.

What I'm dealing with is the browning of the nitrate dope. You might see this as dope stains. In the past I rarely had this issue, if ever. What is posted is the condition of the covering right after the Esaki has dried. I'm hoping that this staining will blend with the application of the classic 50/50 thinner and dope sealant. Do you guys use more than one coat of 50/50 on Esaki? I recall using 2 or more coats on domestic tissue. (Another weight saving from using Esaki tissue).

So here is the story for the "yellow Zero". like I said my brother builds exquisite scale models. Building this stand way off flying scale model was a bit troublesome to his esthetic eye. He then realized that Aurora models in the 60's came out with a Yellow Zero. I think that as a teenager he build one and left it yellow. So this is drawing back on his experience as a youth on that plastic model build so many decades ago.

What I want to ask is how do you guys apply tissue markings to models? How is the chalking process done? Are the marking applied dry or wet? Are they applied now or after the tissue is sealed? I think I'll ask these question in the technique section of the forum.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: TheLurker on May 07, 2026, 10:24 AM
Quote from: KonradWhat I want to ask is how do you guys apply tissue markings to models?
That's a question that will get you n2 answers where n is the number of modellers you ask :)

My preferred technique is...

After covering & doping

EzeDoped models.  Paint the surface with thinned glue stick (I use a nylon 4O brush) following the centre of the item's shape but not out to the borders of the item. Stick it in place then paint a little more thinned glue stick under the edges to seal them.

Cellulose doped models.  Tack the item (letter/number) with down with either dots of thinned glue stick or a few dots of thinners. Then flood/paint the item with more thinners.  When the thinners has gone off a very thin coat of very dilute (20% or less by volume) non-shrinking dope to seal it.

I've not used nitrate dope for umm, errr, well a very long time.  I'd hope it would behave as cellulose dope, but I don't know.  May be worth making up a test panel and trying it out.

Chalking.  Mike Kelly is your man for that I think. 

Novel choice of scheme. I heartily approve.

How did you twist the wing saddles? Did you bend them to follow the curve of the fuselage or warp them to induce washout/in? 
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Jmk89 on May 07, 2026, 12:14 PM
Quote from: Konrad on May 07, 2026, 05:10 AMHow is the chalking process done?


Here are links to two items from the NFFS website :
Pastel Chalk (chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://www.freeflight.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/TissuePastelChalk.pdf)

Pan Pastels (chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://www.freeflight.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Tissue-Coloring-with-Pastels2.pdf)
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on May 07, 2026, 05:39 PM
Quote from: TheLurker on May 07, 2026, 10:24 AM
Quote from: KonradWhat I want to ask is how do you guys apply tissue markings to models?
That's a question that will get you n2 answers where n is the number of modellers you ask :)

...

How did you twist the wing saddles? Did you bend them to follow the curve of the fuselage or warp them to induce washout/in?
So true about the ways to skin a cat ( my apologies to the cat).

I did it the manly way! I just held the hot saddles between my fingers. I still have calluses from when I was a working man. But I like the idea of slowly wrapping them around a broomstick.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on May 07, 2026, 07:29 PM
I know this was a typo. But the warping of the saddles was done only to aid in the construction of the fuselage. There was no intended aerodynamic improvement (trimming aid, wash-out/wash-in).
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jun 29, 2026, 05:58 PM
Wow, it's been about 2 months since I was last here. In that time the Zero has come to life. I like that my brother kept the build light hearted. Here he was masking the canopy with yellow masking tape (Frog brand) in preparation for applying a latex mask. The mask looked great at 5 feet and as there is a high probability that the model will be damaged during flight testing he left the masking tape as the framing.

I have to say I'm really impressed at how well the model looks. I think a lot of this can be traced to the use of old time materials like Esaki Tissue and nitrate dope. But equally it was the time my brother spent sanding.

We did try some 24 test flights, but it really was too windy! Two issue came up. First was that the Zero needed a lot of right and down thrust. Here I'm show that I'm reworking the front bulkhead to add 4.5mm (5°) shim. The second issue is that I can't keep the S hook on the prop shaft. When I get a chance I'll take detail photos and ask for help on troubleshooting.

Some spec's are that the model is 34.8 grams ready to fly with a bit less than 5 grams of nose weight. Power is from 4 strands of 2.6mm x 1mm rubber that are 1.5 time the length of the hook to peg distance, driving a 7" Peck Polymers prop.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jun 29, 2026, 06:55 PM
Any ideas as to why it appears that the S hook climbs (bunches) forward and slips through the prop hook! This has happened 3 times with a wound motor (200 turns). Here is the configuration of the S hook and prop hook.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Piecost on Jun 29, 2026, 10:59 PM
My experience is that a rigid ring on the motor will tend to climb the reverse S hook and even orientate 90 degrees to the axis of rotation. Try using a neoprene O-Ring on the motor instead; it will deform and wrap onto the hook.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jun 30, 2026, 12:26 AM
That's exactly what is happening. This is the first time I've experienced this. Do you have a source for the "O" rings?
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: MKelly on Jun 30, 2026, 02:35 AM
Check the plumbing or faucet repair aisle at Lowes or Home Depot. I get mine there, they have a variety of useful sizes.

Mike
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Jmk89 on Jun 30, 2026, 03:58 AM
In Australia they are called O-rings and they are replacement parts in taps (what our Murrican frenz call faucets), etc.  They come in a variety of sizes.  Choose a size that your motor fits through comfortably leaving just enough space for you to slide it onto the prop hook.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Jmk89 on Jun 30, 2026, 04:06 AM
Here's a picture from our local hardware depot in Australia (Bunnings) - this set costs a few $A.  You can get sets all the one size if you want
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Piecost on Jun 30, 2026, 04:25 AM
Make sure that you test that the O Ring is strong enough before using on your model. For example; IIRC a 1.5mm thickness O Ring was not strong enough for four strands of 1/8" Rubber.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Piecost on Jun 30, 2026, 04:32 AM
I don't know why Crocket hooks; rigid hooks used on Wakefield and Coupe models, do not experience the same problem. I guess that it is due to their  motors not being longer than the propeller to peg length. Perhaps someone  can confirm.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: TheLurker on Jun 30, 2026, 07:23 PM
Quote from: PiecostMake sure that you test that the O Ring is strong enough before using on your model. ...
+1 
I've had them fail as well.  Another possible source, as used by GM, is thin walled, narrow bore neoprene (or similar) tubing.  Take slices off a length of tube as you need them.

The snap is some lengths of tubing G gave me at the last Trinity.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Piecost on Jun 30, 2026, 08:58 PM
Yes, thin walled plastic tube is used on indoor duration models, as flown by GM. Not with reverse S hooks, which tend not to be used much on such models.

I have used the hard plastic tube and was supprised that the edge do not need smoothing.

I like the flexible O rings as they deform and kind-of wrap onto the hook.

Lurker, Is the neoprene flexible or stiff?
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jun 30, 2026, 09:49 PM
Ok guys, we need to go back a bit to some basics. How are the O rings incorporated into the motor?

I assume you find the center point with the strands running in the center of the O-ring. Fold over the  pre wound strands as you would when braiding the motor. The ends of the motor are attached to the rear peg spool as normal. Attach the prop hook to the O-ring and let the motor unwind braiding the motor.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Piecost on Jun 30, 2026, 11:25 PM
For a four strand motor; thread the    loop through the O Ring. Attach one end of the loop onto an anchor, such as a door handle.

Position the O Ring in the middle of the loop. Apply the pre-tension turns. Hold the O Ring and fold the motor, attaching the free end over the anchor.

Attach the winder to the O Ring, and let it dangle and turn to braid the motor.

Only use a single O Ring at the propeller end. No need for one at the peg end. I am not even sure how one could be added there. But, a small rubber band can be useful at the peg end to prevent the motor unraveling. The small silicon Loom bands are a convient and cheap alternative to orthadontic rubber bands.

I have not figured out how to do six strand motor.

Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jul 01, 2026, 03:36 AM
Here is the first flight of the Zero with 100 turns. It really was too windy but what the heck, the wind is from your right. We have about 2 dozen test flight when we quit for the day. We got about 4 flights that did not stress the nose cowl. There was no constant pattern to the flights to aid in trimming. I blame this on the wind. But I'm also coming to the conclusion that I might need more decalage. I measure 3 degrees at the wing root measuring from the bottom of the wing airfoil and the stab.

In this flight and all others I could not get a transition from power to glide. You can see the start of a violent stall to the right (viewed from the cockpit). Other times the stall was to the left. I'm thinking of adding a bit more up decalage and add some nose weight to compensate. In far too many flight where the wind caused the plane to nose up into a prop hanging stall with a flip onto its back. This got the zero up to 5 meters. From here the Zero came straight down with no hint of a pull out. This is leading me to think I need more decalage (up). I'd have expected that as the model gained speed in the dive that the elevator (up trim) would have tried to pull the nose towards the canopy. I never saw the self correcting behavior.

The Zero shows promise both in the initial glide tosses and in the power on section of this video.

https://m.youtube.com/shorts/BHcCiixUQT4?feature=share
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Spiros on Jul 01, 2026, 07:58 AM
From this particular flight, I saw a nice glide path. No nose up and in my opinion the "stall" was due to under power and wind on your left wing. You only had 100 turns

I wouldn't try it on a windy day. You cannot come into a conclusion having such windy weather.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jul 01, 2026, 06:59 PM
Quote from: Spiros on Jul 01, 2026, 07:58 AMFrom this particular flight, I saw a nice glide path. No nose up and in my opinion the "stall" was due to under power and wind on your left wing. You only had 100 turns

I wouldn't try it on a windy day. You cannot come into a conclusion having such windy weather.
I agree that I shouldn't read too much into that day's flights. But two things did appear to be consistent. That is I never got a nice transition from power to glide. I could get some nice glides from a shoulder height launch. And I got a few nice powered flights. But at the end of each powered flight (if I was still in the air) the Zero would transition into a spiral dive, never to recover!

I had about 4 zoom climbs at (200 turns) where the wind drove the nose vertical. The result was that the Zero ended up about 7 meters above the ground hanging on the prop. It then flipped over on its back and dove straight down, making no effort to pull out. It did this about 4 times. I think this is a clue. (I know don't fly in the wind)!

The clue I think I'm seeing is that as the model gains speed in the dive there isn't enough decalage (up trim) to lift the nose towards the canopy. Right now I think the fix is to add up trim to gain this self righting characteristic.  Then add nose weight to find a nice level trim speed. (More nose weight might add some stall margin).
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jul 01, 2026, 08:26 PM
All that talk about nose dives and I think I should say something about the survivability of the model. Key was the addition of a balsa box to support the thrust button. This should take the load off the fragile plastic cowl.

I also cut a slot into the rear of the balsa cowl ring to allow us to add mass (red clay) as far forward as is practical
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: TheLurker on Jul 01, 2026, 08:46 PM
Quote from: PiecostLurker, Is the neoprene flexible or stiff?
The black tubing shown is quite stiff, the clear perhaps a little stiffer than shop-bought O rings.

I'm expecting both to wrap around the hook when I get around to using them.

We now return you to your normal programme.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jul 01, 2026, 10:10 PM
It's all good. Are you using the tubing as a sheath to go around the prop hook? (Not allowing the wire to cut into the rubber motor)?

I'm using the S hook and rear spool to define the ends on my braided motors.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Piecost on Jul 02, 2026, 10:59 AM
A sheath seems like a good idea, but not one that I have bothered with; yet. A bobbin loose fitting onto the peg aids installing the motor and helps to reduce bunching. The bobbin can be seen to be wobbling and partially rotating as the motor unwinds.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jul 02, 2026, 05:56 PM
Quote from: Konrad on May 07, 2026, 01:05 AMThis Zero is being used to reintroduce my brother to the dynamic art of flying models.
Well that was hubris! It has been more than 20 years since I last flew a rubber band scale model. And that was a much larger Comet 24" Hellcat. It is obvious that I'm on the steep learning curve on making a workable power system.

Here is what the power system looks like as flown last weekend. The rubber is about 3 grams (4 strands of 3/32 nominal rubber). The rear spool (bobbin) has been working great. I'm about to disassemble the motor to incorporate the O-ring.

This is a good time to ask what do you use as a motor lube? I was using glycerine. Also how much to you preload the loop before folding it over during the braiding process.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: Konrad on Jul 02, 2026, 06:23 PM
Yikes! I just found out why the thrust line shims apeared to have little or no effect while trimming. The Dumas thrust button will allow the prop shaft to gimbal 10° or more! I will need to come up with a rear suport on the prop shaft to actually allow the shims to effect the thrust line.
Title: Re: Dumas Zero (As a trainer)
Post by: TheLurker on Jul 02, 2026, 09:35 PM
Quote from: Konrad on Jul 01, 2026, 10:10 PMIt's all good. Are you using the tubing as a sheath to go around the prop hook?
No, when I can be bothered, not often, I use heat shrink tubing for that. This sort of thing. (https://www.switchelectronics.co.uk/products/160pcs-black-heat-shrink-assortment-2-1)  I used to get mine from Maplins, they sold one or two yard lengths for not much more than pennies, and I'm still working through it.

The tubing shown above is simply sliced to give a custom width "O" ring.