Well, this is asking for trouble and a liberal helping of egg on the face! :)
Something to do while I wait for good trimming conditions for the Chiribiri.
As I said elsewhere I've wanted a Ryan NYP for a very long time now. My Dumas Ryan M-1 was an attempt to assuage that desire, but I fear all it did was feed it.
For the usual reasons it has to be a Peanut and I wanted the shape to be moderately accurate. This meant those plans that rendered the fuselage aft of the wing as a simple box didn't make the cut.
So, using the Moulton Three View in the June '77 AM (thanks Bill), I've scribbled up my own. Will it work? Dunno. It may turn out to be a lardy old bus with the endurance and flight profile of a house brick, but I'll have fun finding out. I'm not looking for stellar performance with this, anything more than 10 to 15s will be reckoned a success and anything like 25s will be accounted a minor miracle.
As with most of my recent projects this is likely to be a slow build despite its diminutive dimensions. If only because I'm bound to find things that need to be rethought or even that I've drawn bits that are unbuildable. You are allowed to laugh if (when) this happens.
I'm going for a near scale undercarriage stance - wheels in the in-flight position - and no dihedral. My M-1 flies quite nicely with no dihedral and the 1957 Coates NYP did too so room for optimism on that front. Some of the fine details; like the periscope, pitot tube, the wind driven dynamo for the compass and the tiny lettering on the tail will be omitted as out of my reach.
I'll start cutting wood for the fuselage some time this week. The wing will have to wait until I can get an A3 sheet printed because I can't quite fit it on an A4 sheet and I don't much like mucking about with tiled prints.
The α version of the plan is attached for your amusement, or derision, as suits.
That will be an interesting built!
I loved your description though..... ;D
Rock the board!!
That's a nicely done plan Lurk.
i hope you don't think I'm nit picking but the fin/rudder looks a little light on in area to me. I notice that the tail has been increased and I feel that the fin/rudder should match the tail increase ratio.
Good luck.
Agree re. rudder/fin
Agree no dihedral; after all it's a Lacey that you can bear to look at on a shelf. It was by Moulton in 1957 by the way. I built one and it flew with 'invisible hands on each wingtip', just like the blurb. Shame about the consecutive loops.
Bill
OZPAF> ...nicely done plan...
Ta, but as von Moltke didn't quite say, "No plan survives contact with the balsa." :)
OZPAF> ...tail plane...
The tail area is as the Moulton three view and, I believe, scale. No resizing by me.
OZPAF, Bill>..fin...
Yes, it does look worryingly... petite, but it has the same proportions, details below, as the one given on the Moulton plan Not Coates, house point to Bill for spotting my deliberate mistake; yes definitely deliberate not occasioned by stupidity at all. We know the Moulton flew OK with scale proportion tail surfaces so I'm minded to leave things as they are for the moment. It won't be a major set back if a larger fin & rudder does turn out to be required. However, I am expecting it to be as reluctant to turn as my M-1 and the 1957 incarnations of Mr. Moulton's plan.
Fin height
This ~ 45% of tail plane width
Moulton ~ 44% of tail plane width
Fin width
This ~ 80% of tail plane width
Moulton ~ 77% of tail plane width
First wood cut today and am using some of Dusty Millar's beautiful balsa; low density, high strength. Cheap at twice the price.
Formers & strip for fuselage.
I may recut formers F1a. They're the clamp for the UC wire and after I'd cut them it ocurred to me that it may be sensible to go for a denser bit of wood.
The next job is to make up and rough shape the "box" for the front of the fuselage. If I can't get that to work there's no point in going any further.
Today's plan was to get both "boxes" built preparatory to rough shaping. Plans eh? The poetical taxman had things to say about plans. He was right, still; half way there is better than no progress at all. The after box is built. This one requires very little shaping, a bit of chamfering at the top and bottom and that's about it. I'd planned to use 1/8" strip for the fillets, but I have no really light 1/8" so used 3/16" instead. No odds, almost all of it gets sanded away.
Snap No. 1 reminds me. Artists' layout paper, 45gsm. If you don't already use it for your home-printed templates I recommend it. It doesn't dull the blades as quickly as standard 80gsm printer paper and less pressure is needed to cut through it so edges don't get crushed. The latter is v. handy when cutting fine slots & small pieces.
Having got the wood for the fuselage cut, other than the noseblock, I thought I'd try for a rough estimate at a likely fuselage weight. Simply to see whether or not it was going to be a, "lardy old bus".
Formers (as prev. post) 0.19g
Box No.2 (as seen) 0.23g
Box No.3 (bits) 0.33g*
Frame sticks 0.15g**
Longerons/stringer sticks 0.17g**
All runs out to 1.07g which makes me think, allowing for glue and not using all of the wood (esp. the sticks) that an unadorned fuselage weight of somewhere around 1.25g - 1.50g is probable. For comparison my Moorhouse Comper Swift's fuselage came in at 0.93g. Not wonderful, but not, so far, shaping up to be a boat anchor.
*I'm expecting the box to be a bit lighter when built, the paper currently stuck to the bits will be lost and there's quite a bit of wood to be sanded away.
**These are the weights for the uncut, overlong, sticks.
Box No. 3!? Idiot. Box No.1. I blame the heat.
Very neatly done Lurk.. that is very nice wood too isn't it
Right, I can build a passable front bit for the fuselage. It looks about right when held against the plan so it'll do. See the snaps.
Box as seen 0.49g & the nose plug opening adds 0.07g. It may be possible to sand another one or two hundreths of a gramme out of it, but I rather think I'm going to need a bit of weight up front.
As expected Von Moltke's dictum applies to the build. First, cough, amendment. The fillets need to be 3/16" rather than 1/8" for both boxes. If this were laser cut 1/8" might just be possible, but that leaves no wriggle room at all when shaping.
Next potential "stopper" is the motor, so that's up next. However it's Trinity on Sat. and it's a newsletter month so won't be starting on the motor until that's out the door.
Nice work!
Finally made a start on the Wright Whirlwind J5 yesterday.
Cylinder blanks made using the traditional thread on a dowel method. One of the very, very few fabrication steps where cyano is my adhesive of choice.
The only things that might be new(ish) are
- I use button thread rather than ordinary sewing thread, it's a wee bit thicker and I think it gives a more convinincing result.
- I glue (yes, cyano) the balsa dowel to some cheap pine dowel (from Hobbycraft or the like) to make it easier to hold and rotate as I'm winding the thread.
1 Start
2 One hour later
3 Separated and...
4 Painted
Looks about the right size for bendy straws - the bendy bit.
Quote from: billdennis747 on Jul 30, 2026, 11:23 PMLooks about the right size for bendy straws - the bendy bit.
Yebbut... I gave all the bendy elbow bits I'd gathered to someone at Trinity a year or two back and I have the devil's own job of getting plastic and wood to stay stuck together for any length of time. Especially when bits are subject to my ham-fisted trimming.
Now here's something to whet your collective appetite. Maybe.
You may remember I experimented with tinfoil a wee while ago to see if I could get a decent looking engine turned finish. You can, but foil-wood adhesion was poor and I could foresee issues with the compound curves of the NYP's nose and of course fag packet liners with that very fine foil that would take a compound curve are no longer a thing.
Anyway... as a consequence of several things, including a natter about toy aeroplanes and their construction at a family gathering, the idea of gilding
finally occurred to me. Happily for me, as well as genuine gold (and silver) leaf, you can buy "fake" leaf in "gold", "silver" (Al rather than Ag) and copper colours.
This weekend's (*) experiments (yes plural - bound to stuff it up several times) will be in "silver" gilding. This will either be an expensive failure, the bits in the snap made 50 quid look silly, or the dawn of glorious new age in metallic finishes for small model aeroplanes. I'm not betting on the dawn of a ect ect ect. Chiz. :)
The main questions to be answered are:
- Can I prepare the surfaces well enough to get a smooth finish without wrinkles?
- Will it cope well with compound curves?
I expect it to given its extensive use for intricately carved rococo picture frames (https://theframeblog.com/2013/05/17/carving-gilding-a-british-rococo-frame/). But...- Will it be robust enough?
- Will it survive an attempt to mimic engine turning?
(*) Could be more than a weekend. We shall see.
If it proves moderately robust, but won't take any kind of abrading for the engine turning then I expect to be able to use the idea for polished Al engine cowlings.
Stay tuned for more
exciting developments.
I did engine turning on an aluminium cowling for a Sopwith Triplane and it looked great. I just used a dowel with a hole punched disc of wet and dry stuck to the end and twizzled on the aluminium. But I did use a template with a short row of holes punched in, to keep the dowel twizzles in a regular-ish line.
Quote from: billdennis747 on Jul 31, 2026, 10:51 PM...did use a template with a short row of holes punched in, to keep the dowel twizzles in a regular-ish line.
That is an excellent idea, consider it
nicked snaffled ahem
adopted. :)
Quote from: TheLurkerNow here's something to whet your collective appetite. Maybe.
Yup. duly whetted.
I had a big clear-out recently and had to decide what to do with some leaves of ackshual Ag silver leaf I bought years ago but never tried. It disintegrated even as I tried to separate it from its thin paper protective backing. In the bin. Good luck with the Al.
Stephen.
Quote from: Prosper on Aug 01, 2026, 05:30 PM...had to decide what to do with some leaves of ackshual Ag silver leaf I bought years ago but never tried.
They're obviously paying you too much. Real Ag! Bai Eck. Looxury! When I wur a lad... :)
All the tutorials say something like, "Start with a flat piece of wood...", but we're aeromodellers and how many of us started with a simple glider as recommended in all the beginners' guides? Aye, right. Not one single one of us. Anyway I needed to know sooner rather than later whether or not this was going to work for compound curves so I dug out one of the many, oh so many, spare nose blocks I made for my VMC MfM Camel to use as a test piece.
First up prep. I wanted to see what the bare minimum prep. I could get away with was. I'm lazy, so shoot me. :)
Sand back, fill any big dents with my usual PVA, talc & H20 "gesso", flat and prime with white (Windsor & Newton, Galeria) acrylic. When I was picking the brains of one of the artists in our local studios about how to gild wood she suggested acrylic and even at a push emulsion as cheap & good alternatives to the proper gilder's gesso.
1 - Start
2, 3 fill & flat
4 primed
Applying the leaf. A few mistakes made, but for a first go I'm well satisfied.
The initial result. A bit more prep will be required if an absolutely mirror perfect surface is to be represented, but at arm's length (last snap) "bare min." prep seems to be just about enough.
Out of the box the leaf gives a very high shine, perhaps too high for a small model, but a thin film of matt varnish should deal with that if a duller finish is needed. The usual recommendation is to seal with a varnish for real Au & Ag to prevent tarnishing as well as improve durability.
I had a quick go with a small flat test piece to see if the leaf would stand up to being "twizzled" (thank you Bill). It does, if you're exceedingly gentle and I think the effect is going to be good enough for the NYP. Unfortunately my camera can't cope with the glare as well as the MKI eyeball so it's not that easy to see in the pictures.
The last experiment was to see if I could represent an oxidized / weathered aluminium surface as you'd see on an much used in-service aircraft. A very, very gentle scouring with flour paper seems to do the trick.
Conclusion.
The Al leaf "gilding" looks as though it will give a satisfactory result and allow me to at least hint at an engine turned finish even if it's not possible to get the sort of result that's possible with tinfoil.
I also suspect, but cannot prove, that the leaf will be no heavier than two or three coats of flat Al acryic paint. It may even be lighter.
Quote from: TheLurkerThey're obviously paying you too much. Real Ag! Bai Eck. Looxury! When I wur a lad... :)
Well the weight of silver I threw away must be miniscule. I did wonder what else it might be useful for but drew a blank.
Yest. evening I re-watched 'The Spirit of St Louis' film, (1957). As aviation films go, it's really good. There's a brief glimpse of engine-turning - see attached screenshot. The film is available to watch or download from the Internet Archive, if anyone's interested.
https://archive.org/details/the-spirit-of-st.-louis-1957
Dunno about the video quality of that particular print.
Interesting work Lurk, thanks for showing the details. This makes me wonder whether the brass leaf could be successfully applied over tissue to represent the wing radiators on some 1920s and 1930s racers such as the Macchis.
Mike
Quote from: MKelly on Aug 02, 2026, 07:31 PM... makes me wonder whether the brass leaf could be successfully applied over tissue to represent the wing radiators...
Short answer would seem to be yes. Very quick experiment with an old spare wing shows it's possible, but there are wrinkles to be ironed out if you want first rate results.
Main problem is getting the tack time for the gilding medium right. On a 20% by volume doped (indoor use) wing, the usual 5-10 minutes for a commonly used medium(*) is too long. It just soaks in and dries out. It sort of worked at 2 or 3 minutes, but you can see where I had to re-apply part of the leaf. It may be that very, very thin dope, 5% or more dilute, would be better than gilding medium, that or a medium may work on a highly doped, less porous, wing. A set of experiments for anyone who may be interested.
It's likely you'd need to seal the "gilding" with a thin layer of very dilute dope after it was applied to ensure some measure of durability.
Cheers,
Lurk
(*) I'm using Robertson's Ormoline Gilding Medium which is an acrylic based "instant" gilding medium. There are lots of others out there and one or more of them may be better suited to gilding paper. Wouldn't know, I'm only about two paragraphs ahead of you in the tutorial. :)
Thanks for trying that experiment Lurk, looks promising. I'd think one would want a structure under the tissue that minimized sag between the ribs, and a fairly thorough sealing job on the tissue before applying the leaf. I wonder if capillary action would be sufficient to pull thinners under the leaf and create a bond with the doped tissue? Probably would want to go with strips of leaf for each rib bay, or possibly even narrower, maybe mimicking the sections of the full-size radiators.
Hmmm...
Meanwhile, enjoying watching your Ryan coming together.
Cheers,
Mike
Has anyone realised yet that the Lindbergh flight took place on May 20-21 1927? And that the final assembly at San Diego took place on April 27 in time for the maiden flight on April 28?
Quote from: Stunthenk on Aug 07, 2026, 08:57 PMHas anyone realised yet that the Lindbergh flight took place on May 20-21 1927?
Ummm. Yes. :)
I would never have thought of using leaf - great idea and looks to be working well!
Tim
Quote from: THB on Aug 08, 2026, 12:01 PMI would never have thought of using leaf - great idea and looks to be working well!
Tim
Henk has a better idea, he's (possibly) going to try the bare metal foil the plastics crowd use on his F VII. Wish I'd thought of it, probably far easier and certainly much cheaper. :)
Quote from: StunthenkHas anyone realised yet that the Lindbergh flight took place on May 20-21 1927?
Yes, I was thinking of that all through when I watched the movie. I was going to mention it here but I'm too stunned -
100 years?? Impossible!
Every summer I get an urge to Build an NX-211 model - gotta commit next year, surely . . .
Stephen.
Quote from: Prosper on Aug 09, 2026, 12:53 PMQuote from: StunthenkHas anyone realised yet that the Lindbergh flight took place on May 20-21 1927?
Yes, I was thinking of that all through when I watched the movie. I was going to mention it here but I'm too stunned - 100 years?? Impossible!
Every summer I get an urge to Build an NX-211 model - gotta commit next year, surely . . .
Stephen.
The thing that rattled me was when I was given a copy of the June '77 issue of AM, which I'd had new, and realising it nigh on was half a century since I'd read it.
Time flies eh? Unlike my models. Ho hum.
Stephen> ...Every summer I get an urge to Build an NX-211 model...
There
may be a Peanut plan available in a few weeks/months time. :)
As I mentioned, the first flight of the NYP took place on 28 April 1927. And which event is scheduled to take place on 25 April, 2027? Close enough? (Hint, hint....)
If I can make mine fly, it will be at Walsall all else being well.
It was always my intention to have it ready for the Indoor Scale Nats as well as the centenary, but I hadn't realised the near match to the maiden flight date.
Anyway... got to have something to new fly now that my planned entry for intermediate, the Chiribiri, is in bits in the bin.
Wouldn't it be nice if there were one or two more there? Would Mr. Prosper please go to the white courtesy telephone in the foyer. Would Mr. Prosper....
Thanks for the link to the film Stephen - it's an old favourite of mine.
On learning that replica's had been made for the film I came across the following interesting story and flight of a very authentic replica.
NYP replica flight to a Museum in May this year
https://www.facebook.com/reel/2143638989754194
Also some of the construction photos by JNE Aircraft
https://www.jneaircraft.com/sosl
JNE videos of NYP flying
https://www.youtube.com/@JNEAircraft/videos
JNE facebook page
https://www.facebook.com/jnespirit
Lots of pics and a possible source of good reference material.
John
Have been busy with other things so all I've managed to do this last week or so is get part way through the motor/nose block. That's OK though, 'cos this was a potential stopper. Needs the holes for the remaining cylinders reaming out, nose plug fitted and sanding to final shape.
I think it's likely the exhaust stubs will be left off until it's trimmed and they may not even be added if I find that they're too fragile to withstand repeated removal and replacement of the nose block.
You'd thought I'd abandoned this hadn't you? No such luck, just been a bit busy.
The first go at reaming out the cylinder holes didn't work, too fragile, so it was back to the drawing board. This is better, but (note to self) in future dry fit the cylinder separators first to make sure you get a much more even distribution. As it is they're not badly off, but some are and it rankles. :)
It would be easier to make the motor with all disks, sand the taper in and then slice the bottom of the cylinders to fit the slope, but this assembly is likely to get mauled in everyday use and I want the cylinders to stay put. As much as I like my Dumas Ryan M-1 it does get a bit tedious hunting round the floor for cylinders when they get knocked off.
1 Fitting the cylinder separators.
2 Pack the gaps with dowel while sanding.
3 Extract the dowel.
4 High technology tooling. :)
Got there in the end.
The rocker covers and con-rods will be fitted towards the end of the build to reduce the risk of damage during construction.
Haven't got a clue how I'm going to do deal with the spinner, but that can wait until nearer the end of the build.
Combined weight as seen is a shade under 2.5g of which 1g is the fuselage "box". As long as the fuselage inc. "box" comes in somewhere close to 2g I think it'll probably be OK. The NYP has a fairly short nose so built in weight up front is not necessarily going to be a bad thing.
1 - Motor/ nose block. Built in right-thrust and down-thrust are about 2 deg.
2,3 - Nose block plugged in to fuselage box
Tell you something for nothing, the next one is going to have an in-line engine!
On to the easy(ish) bit now. Fuselage &tc.
3-D engine cylinders are hard! Good to see someone working on an engine for a smaller plane. Looks good. 90% done, 90% to go.
ian
We have a fuselage. At last. Just taped togther for the snaps. The box needs another go over with fine sandpaper before it gets glued to the the rest of the framework.
For those keeping count, the fuselage weight (framework + nose box) is 1.6g.
The motor/nose block in its current state is 1.5g.
This is not going to be an especially light model. Oh well.
Very neat Lurk
Only the easy parts to go :) It will look very impressive.
John
It's looking very good, Lurk. I may have missed it, but have you said how you're doing the overall colour? Ie. Sprayed, or with silver tissue? Or maybe some other sneaky method?
I have an ulterior motive for asking, having just got a Curtiss Robin kit on eBay which may well be my next kit scale entry. I'm highly tempted to finish the Robin as Douglas 'Wrong Way' Corrigan's aircraft, which was also silvery grey.
(Corrigan, you probably know, worked on the Ryan NYP, and was consequently inspired by Lindbergh's success to follow his own Atlantic ambitions.)
Quote from: Pete Fardell on Sep 09, 2026, 12:47 PM....have you said how you're doing the overall colour? Ie. Sprayed, or with silver tissue? Or maybe some other sneaky method?
I have discussed it, but probably only in e-mail messages with various Trinity bods. At the moment it is most likely to be a very light grey tissue finish.
I have some lovely lightweight Ag/Al tissue from Peck/Wind-it-Up that is under consideration, but it may be /too/ shiny, N-X-211 has quite a flat finish. I also have yet to test it to see how well it shrinks. My previous results with (VMC's) Ag/Al tissue were, at best, barely adequate. If it shrinks well and is fairly easy to work with I may use it instead of the light grey. Stay tuned in for more ...
A sprayed (rattle-can) finish is almost certainly not going to happen. I did think about it, but I think this model is too small and keeping the weight down is too important to risk it as my first attempt at a painted finish.
In other news. This evening saw the correction of a minor cock-up in the fuselage, photo another day, likewise the mistake on the plan that gave rise to it and the boiling and setting up of the tail outlines. Bill & John (Ozpaf) will be pleased to hear that the rudder area has been increased by 8.5% c.f. the α version of the plan.
It may surprise you to know that The Lurker Industries Aviation Co. Ltd.(Reg. Office Lechlade-On-Thames) maintains a close working relationship with Melrose Aeronautical Engineers (Sole Prop. Peter Smart. Gent.)
Having been told this you may not be surprised to hear that Mr. Smart requested a pre-release copy of the plan to carry out a test build. The Co. was pleased to supply same and to have Trinity's resident Stakhanovite set to.
Levity to one side. Peter couldn't get his build to co-operate at Trinity today for various reasons, but there are some very useful data that have come out of his build.
- An easier way to build the fuselage. Peter found the former based approach I've used... challenging. He gave up after 3 goes at it. When (if) I've got mine flying I'll redraw the plan using his box and stringer solution.
- The confirmation that the tail-plane does indeed need to be bigger.
- A simple and effective way to represent the engine turning on the nose. Briefly; an Al painted ground and then use a dark Al/Ag pen dotted on to that. I'll get the brand of pen he used next time I e-mail him. The dots on Peter's are on the large side, but even at that the effect from short arm's length is better than passable.
- The rest of it is fairly buildable, which is reassuring.
Enough natter. Some snaps.
Very interestin'. Re. my previous post about getting an urge to model NX211 every summer, the tiny tailplane is one of the off-putting factors. Bill Dennis has said that he has few qualms about small tailplanes (my interpretation of Bill's words), and I agree with him - I've flown rubber scale models with tailplanes 14% of wing area without problems - but I don't remember if NX211 even attains 14%.
Stephen.
Bit of arithmetic and redrawing this evening.
Running DeLoach's approximation over various permutations of tail plane size and it looks as though a 9% oversized (by area) tail plane will be about right for stability and won't look stupidly large.
I've increased the span rather than chord as I read somewhere (no, I really can't remember where), but it was years and years ago that a span-wise increase was more effective than a chord-wise increase. Whether that's true or not I think a span-wise increase is less jarring to the eye
For those who need to know these things.
A 9% increase in area increases Vh (TVo) from 0.6 to 0.74 and gives an approx. CG position at 42% root chord.
A 4.5% increase in area increases Vh (TVo) to 0.66 and gives an approx. CG of 40% root chord.
DeLoach advises that for FF scale models that 0.66 <= Vh <= 0.75 is likely to give best results.
Of course this is all "wet finger in the air" with a large dash of haruspexy thrown in, but it's a bit better than wild guesses.
I haven't seen 'haruspex' since high school Latin classes (when it was not unusual for me to be thinking about something I'd read in the latest AeroModeller rather than the third declension).
Quote from: Jmk89I haven't seen 'haruspex' since high school Latin classes . . .
I 'ent never sin it before. Forced to go to the dictionary. Lurk, the entrails of which animal did you use to make your divination? Not your pet cat, I hope. Re. the tailplane, I think that there are two things at play here - generally, a higher aspect ratio planform is always better for lifting surfaces; and propwash blanketing the tail surfaces is a bad thing, so extending the tailplane span out of the wash is a good idea. In your case I expect the whole tailplane will still be washed over, but perhaps less so at the tips.
Stephen.
Quote from: Prosper on Sep 17, 2026, 03:35 PM...the entrails of which animal...
Weel, chickens are traditional and you can eat the bits not needed for the divination. Waste not, want not. :)
Whilst I agree with Prosper that increased span (aspect ratio) will increase the effectiveness of the tailplane. I respectfully disagree about propeller slipstream;
At higher power the increased airflow over the tail will increase its effectiveness. But, this tends to be overwhelmed by the destabalising effect of the propeller.
On lower power the propeller may actuallynbe reducing the airflow over the tail (blanking it), but the much reduced destabalising effect of the propeller will be dominant.
So, the stability tends to be lower at high power.
This is generally applicable, but depends on propeller characteristics and airframe geometry etc.
I think that a smaller, faster prop tends to be better than a larger one as it has less destabalising effects and blows more air over the tail. But; I'd be interested to hear other opinions.
Yes, that's it, as I understand it - the accelerated airflow over the tail surfaces makes them more effective in terms of static stability - but that same airflow from the propeller blankets the tail surfaces from the freestream airflow somewhat, thus reducing dynamic stability - responsiveness to gusts and turbulence generally. There are pictures of piston-engined planes in humid environments - typically on board aircraft carriers - where the helical propwash vortex is visible. I'd like to know whether the vortex diminishes in diameter as it travels aft.
Stephen.
Good point Prosper; I tend to forgot dynamic stability. It makes sense that the the slipstream blowing over the tail deminishes the the change in downwash that thw tailplane see, as the aeroplane pitches. Yes, the prop wash does contract slightly begind the propeller. I would need to check momentum theory to quantify it. But, this is digressing from Lurkers nice model.
I was going to say, "Digress away!" as I do like a thread that rambles, but it's not really a digression. It has a direct bearing on the likelihood of getting the end result to fly.
Back to the digression...
This is a screanshot from a video that came up on my Youtube stream. It nicely shows the condensation in the propeller tip vortices. Even though the visible vortices don't make it back to the tail; the stream of fast moving air does.
A contraction in diameter can be seen just behind the propeller. Similar to wingtip vortices. There also seems to be a general contraction as the air moves further aft.
I can convince myself that the canopy causes a bulge in the slipstream "stream tube"
Great illustration Piecost - shows the real deal. I must say though that if I continue that visible contraction of the vortex to the tail . . . it still blankets the whole tail.
Having made scale (I mean fully-scale) models of both Me.109 and Fw.190 - both of which have ~14% Hz stabiliser area to wing area . . . the Fw.190 was more stable despite its longer nose (nose ahead of the CG). Perhaps because it has a high aspect ratio tailplane compared to the 109.
Frankly, at the low Reynolds numbers we deal with with our small, scale, models . . . there are so many variables and confounding factors - known and unknown, as per Donald Rumsfeld (?sp). An example is the phenomenally thick aerofoil sections of the Hawker Hurricane/Typhoon/Tempest. Combined with small tail area relative to wing area, the super-thick tailplanes destroy pitch stability. Bin there - don't want to go there again.
Sorry Lurk - hope I haven't digressed a digression too far.
Stephen.PS just seen your post Tim-yes the bubble canopy is one of those known onknowns
QuoteSorry Lurk - hope I haven't digressed a digression too far.
I'm afraid I would like to add to the digression!
As your interesting photo indicates Piecost - the propwash stream tube would definitely appear to contract on leaving the propeller in a high velocity stream tube. However I believe it slowly increases in diameter as the the velocity reduces - a fair way behind the tail. A similar situation to the changes that occur with wing down wash.
As Stephen mentions - there are too many unknown variables and experience while considering theory, is probably the best approach.
Apologies Lurk.
John
No access to a building board for a fortnight so tinkering with "artwork". Have spent some time getting the nose "art" as right as I can. A task I'd been putting off because there's an absolute dearth of good, large images to trace.
Given this what I have is a long way from perfect, but as it's going to be tiny (8mm x 20mm) I think, assuming I can get it in place, the inaccuracies aren't going to be terribly obvious.
Applying it is going to be a real challenge. The lowercase letters are about 2mm high. I can usually manage to cut passable tissue lettering (my preferred solution, every time) down to about 6mm. One third that size and convoluted with it... well. At the moment I'm wondering if pouncing (using talc) and then painting in with a v. fine brush or pen would work. An experiment for when I get back home.
You wouldn't consider printing the artwork onto the tissue used for the nose section, Lurk?
John
Morning John,
The plan is to cover the nose with aluminium leaf and 'twizzle' it to get an engine turned effect so the name will have to be applied as separate letters; either tissue or paint/ink.
However it happens it's going to be a slow old job with lots, oooh lots and lots, of room for making a mess of it. :)
That was a massive oversight on my part ;D Engine turning printed on silver coloured tissue ?
Hmm! I guess it would not do the model justice!
John
Finally able to get some work done this weekend.
One wing, waiting shaped tips, & a new outline for the, now, slightly enlarged tail-plane.
The new tail outline needs at least another couple of days to set properly, but hope to make a start on the fin & rudder tomorrow.
On to the fin & rudder. Lot of hurry up & wait in this hobby; this is a couple of evenings effort.
1 - Glue the rudder post & rudder LE at the desired separation.
2 - Lift off the board & insert hinges.
3 - Pin down & build the rest, slowly. :)
4 - And we're done.
Compact wee beastie isn't it? Outline is 1/20 x 1/32 basswood the remainder is some delightful stiff 5 lb/cu.ft 1/20" stock I got from Dusty Millar a few months ago.
Next little bit. The tail-plane. More pins Igor!
Also made a start on the spinner/prop. Probably have yoghurt pot blades. Got to find a yoghurt pot though...
The Al tube is cyano-ed to the ply disk just to keep it aligned while the balsa discs are fitted. The first couple of balsa disks are fixed with epoxy to ensure a solid fixing to the Al tube. The remainder have been fixed with PVA. If time allows I'll shape it tomorrow,
Spinner finished. It probably took longer to make the profile gauge than it did pare & sand it to the final shape. The prop. shaft will be secured with a thin smear of 5 minute epoxy.
1 - Profile gauge(*) for final check & marked up for rough shaping.
2 - Roughly shaped.
3 - Final check of shape
4 - In situ. May have overcooked the baked in right thrust, but that's fixable.
(*) Like Chris, I don't have a lathe. :)
And after today's go at the spinner, tomorrow's (or maybe the day afterwards) task...
This one is going to be hand launch only, there just isn't enough UC clearance to allow for anything approaching a reasonable diameter airscrew.
Plodding on.
1 - One spinner & prop assembly. It's 4" diameter and the pitch is close to that of the equivalent dia. Peck/VMC prop. I'm hoping that I'll be able to trim it down during trimming so that ROG is possible, but no matter if I can't.
2,3 - Wheels. Blanks & part done. No startling new techniques here. Four by 1/32" layers x-grain per wheel, fine Al tube axle. Solid discs for the core & hoops for the tyres. I'll finish shaping the second wheel tomorrow or Friday. Long past this Lurker's bed time and it'd be silly to rush it. :)
Haven't been able to find a good head on image of the wheels for gauging the width, but in the snaps I have they look to be about the same width as the suspension fairing on the strut. So laminate and when all set sand the tyres down to about 1/64" thickness on each side. Looks about right.
A bit of experimentation today. Nose legends. Now, given the size, the ideal solution for crisp lettering and ease of application would be waterslide transfers, but for (perverse) reasons of my own I want to see if a decent result can be achieved by simpler (and cheaper) means.
1 - Lettering on test panel. I'd hoped to be able to use tissue, but the lettering is just too small and cutting through tape, template and tissue in this case turned into a waste of tissue. So I've gone for artists' layout paper (45gsm) instead. The results aren't too bad and the inevitable white edges are, mostly, lost against the aluminium ground. The letters won't sit as flush to the surface as tissue would, but I'll live with it.
2, 3 Positioning the letters. The experiment with carbon paper glued to a template and tracing on to the test panel to give a guide was a miserable failure hem hem less successful than one had hoped for. So back to my usual technique for lettering positioning :)
4 Position template roughly place. Will thin use low tack masking tape to keep it in place. I can see me having a lot of type II fun actually placing the letters, but heigh ho.
Light's going here now so the port side lettering will have to be cut tomorrow.
Scooz me for being thick, but could you elaborate on your caption for pic.1 in the above post? I don't follow what you've done. The result looks v. impressive so I want to find out more. I did check back to post #58 in case that sets the scene for what you've done here, but it made things no clearer for me.
Stephen.
Quote from: Prosper on Nov 01, 2026, 03:33 PM...could you elaborate on your caption for pic.1 in the above post?
Sorry it wasn't clear. What I usually do is print the lettering template on 45gsm paper, tape it over appropriately coloured tissue and cut through. To save ink I print the templates as outline only. It didn't work this time, I wasn't expecting it to, so I printed the nose legends as solid colour to 45gsm and cut those out. That make more sense?
Today. Cut out the port side nose legend letters, took around forty five mins to an hour, and did the "engine turning" on the nose. The engine/machine turning isn't great, but squinting from long arms length it
just about passes muster. Intending to start applying the lettering tomorrow after work, but it's a job that will require a fair amount of concentration so it will depend on how puggled I am.
Looking at what's left to do there is the very,
very, slimmest of chances, if the stars align just so, that I'll have something testable for the next Trinity.
1 - Nose "gilded". Aluminiumed?
2 - With nose block in for giggles.
3 - "Turned". Had to do this freehand. Tried using a guide as Bill suggested, but the piece is too small to hold the guide, nose & "twizzler".
4 - Testing that I can glue small letters to Al foil/gilding and that they'll stay put.
Quote from: TheLurker. . .What I usually do is print the lettering template on 45gsm paper, tape it over appropriately coloured tissue and cut through.
What - so you done all them tiny spiral squiggly bits by cutting, with a scalpel blade? That's what wasn't clear to me - I didn't think such a thing feasible at that scale (known as 50p scale). Kudos.
The engine turning looks really good. More kudos.
Stephen.
Quote from: Prosper on Nov 02, 2026, 01:33 AMWhat - so you done all them tiny spiral squiggly bits by cutting, with a scalpel blade?
Alas, as much as I would like to claim to be some kind of micro/nano-cutting whiz I cannot. Chiz, chiz, chiz. :)
If you have a dekko at the attached you'll see that I've cut in fairly close to the tight spirals for the port S & both 'r's, but not all the way in. I did cut all the way into the spiral for the stbd S. I also separated the o & f in "of" for the stbd side. I think I'll recut those to match the port side, they'll be far easier to manipulate when I come to glue them on and slightly less likely to tear/fold when being placed. I did make a point of "punching out" the centres of the "P" and "O"s though.
1 - Port
2 - Stbd
3 - Where (& when) this all got started.
Too bushed to be able to concentrate on very small scale detail i.e. fixing the nose legends in place, see prev., today so finished off the wheels instead.
1 - Tissue discs backed with 45gsm paper
2 - Test fit
3 - Done & dusted.
One day I'll make some exactly circular wheels, not anytime soon thought.
Thanks for elucidating, Lurk. Great work.
Stephen.
Work, the curse of the aeromodelling classes. Two days, two days! And what do I have to show for it? Some wing tips. Well... some shaped wing tips & the LE & TE have been sanded to profile too, but still... wanders off, grumbling, muttering and shaking fist at the clouds.
Come to the IFFI in Wijchen and all your frustrations will disappear in wonder and awe.... But will resurface and haunt you untill you can do as well as THEM... Now, how do I know that? (come anyway)
Quote from: Stunthenk on Nov 04, 2026, 10:36 PMCome to the IFFI in Wijchen ... haunt you untill you can do as well as THEM
Ahh, I don't need to brave the Howling Tempest Tossed North Sea to be made to feel inadequate or frustrated, I can get that at Trinity watching Gerard's, the Peters' (Smart & Brown), Steve H's, Andy B's and others' models flying. Mind you the prospect of good Dutch coffee, which is second only to Greek coffee, is a powerful draw.... :)
I wish I'd realised before yesterday that proxy flying was allowed for the Peanut & Pistachio classes, I'd have sent my Moorhouse Comper Swift along. Never mind.
Anyway, to business!
Today we have the traditional (for me) grand cock-up on the decorating front, see below. I shan't bother to correct this for several reasons; first it's a useful corrective to any tendency to swank and second it would mean re-doing the whole nose from a fresh coat of leaf so let it stand as a lesson in making sure your template is aligned properly. A tertiary benefit is that I'm able to stand by my earlier promise to provide everyone with a little schadenfreude. :)
1 - Stbd nose legend
2 - Port nose legend. Spot the cock-up?
3,4 - Serials & fin legends.
I thought I'd see how well I'd get on with cutting the smaller tail lettering from tissue. I may have another go tomorrow, see if I can get a more uniform result. If not I'll be "inking in" the fin legends from the reverse of the tissue.
At last! The obligatory bones snaps and weigh in. There are still a few bits to add but I'm now in a position to start covering.
The nose has been given a couple of thin coats of matt acrylic spray varnish. I considered a satin finish, but I think the matt will look better with the grey tissue I'll be using for the rest of it. Either way a coat of varnish is vital, the leaf doesn't take a lot of abrasion so needs it.
The red smudge on the spinner is the reflection of my jumper. It's "gilded" with a coat of thinned NS dope for abrasion resistance.
If you can't read it weight as seen is 6.43g so I'm hoping for a sub 10g built weight. Left to do ...
- Fillet at LE over nose
- Motor peg
- Prop. shaft.
- Struts
- Rocker covers & (possibly) con-rods.
- Covering
Most of the weight for the prop shaft is accounted for above in the untrimmed length of UC wire.
It's looking highly unlikely it'll be testable in time for next Saturday's Trinity. A bit of shame, but there you go.
Lurk
I see that you have reached 500 posts and are now a hero member. Congratulations
I'll have a gues at the difference between port and stbd lettering. The lettering on the port side seems to have larger spaces between the letters.
If that is not the issue then it is even less obvious to me. As my Dad would have said:"Blind Freddy running for his life in a fire won't notice it".
More importantly, I know from bitter experience that the builder sees the mistakes in their creations as if they are disfiguring scars while others either do not see them or, if they do, only observe a curious feature!
Looking very nice! And I agree: never point out your mistakes; the viewers (judges!) must spot them theirselves.
That is light Lurk. I'm still amazed at the size of the letters - it all looks very neat to me down under :)
John
I love the patterened aluminium nose and lettering. This is turning out to be a stunning model.
It's looking very nice indeed, Lurk.
Btw, are you following the latest exploits of the Old Rhinebeck replica?
https://flyer.co.uk/feature/spirit-of-st-louis-replica-to-fly-1250-miles-with-original-wright-engine/ (https://flyer.co.uk/feature/spirit-of-st-louis-replica-to-fly-1250-miles-with-original-wright-engine/)
Quote from: Pete Fardell on Nov 12, 2026, 12:13 PMBtw, are you following the latest exploits of the Old Rhinebeck replica?
I wasn't even aware of it! Mind you they are cheating,
anyone can do 1:1. :)
Any Trinity bods here? Just so you know I'm pulling a Doolittle, the parish mag. will be late this time. :)
Sorry, but have to get this ready for testing in Dec. to stand any chance of it being ready for April. I can see there being quite a bit of fiddling with decalage if nothing else. And we won't mention the elephant in the workshop.
To which end. Fitting the rocker covers to the motor. Effort about 50 mins, elapsed? About 9 hours. There was a lot of waiting for glue to dry between each rocker cover.
1 - Using the con-rods (guitar "strings") to get the covers aligned.
2 - Part way through.
3 - Receiving holes for con-rods drilled. Couple in place to show effect. Waiting final shaping of the rocker covers, fitting of con-rods & paint.
That is an odd place for "conrods" to be, outside the cylinders. I think you meant to say "pushrods".
Paul
One house point for spotting the *cough* deliberate mistake. :)
Beautiful build as always Lurks. Love your work. Not sure how to say this, but comparing your UK coinage to your model is of limited assistance to those who trade in other currency :) :D ;D
Plus when does your currency depict the King - ie: Elvis :) :D ;D
Quote from: THB on Nov 16, 2026, 11:01 AMNot sure how to say this, but comparing your UK coinage to your model is of limited assistance to those who trade in other currency...
There are currencies other than Sterling? When did
that happen? Just be grateful I didn't ferret around in my bag of pre-decimal coins for a farthing, tanner or 1/2d or 1d. :)
I could have confused things still further by using the old, larger, 50p coin. Hee hee.
Quote from: THBPlus when does your currency depict the King - ie: Elvis :) :D ;D
The new currency notes already feature Big Ears and a new set of coins is due out soonish. The "tail" side will feature endangered animals, many with tails!
The Royal Mint have already issued some sort of commerative half crown for Elvis - go ogle for details
1 - By popular demand The Customer Relations Dept. of The Lurker Industries Aviation Co. Ltd. is pleased to provide free of charge, gratis and for nothing this handy cut out and keep scaling guide for those who are not fortunate enough to live in these Septic Sceptred Isles. Additional copies (1) may be had by sending an SAE with a postal order for 3/6d to the usual address. For two or more copies please add 2d per additional copy. Please allow 28 days for delivery.
2,3 Back in a less whimsical world, although perhaps only marginally so, the nose block / motor is done. I'm not going to add the inlets & exhausts they'll just get knocked off in the rough & tumble of everyday flying.
Very neat indeed, pity about the intake and exhaust pipes as you have done such a Stirling job of the rest of it.