HPA

Scale Free Flight Forum => Scale, outdoor => Topic started by: Piecost on Aug 04, 2026, 02:39 PM

Title: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 04, 2026, 02:39 PM
This build is a continuation of a project started 40 years ago. My father and I constructed a 480mm (18.9") span Humbrol Tiger Moth.

The kit included nice light balsa for the sheet fuselage and tail, built-up wings and rather thick and heavy vacuum formed fuselage top decking and nose cowling.

We originally built it for rubber power, unpainted with a bright green propeller. I have a fond memory of it flying well for a short straight flight in my front garden. This strong positive memory ensired my motivation for free flight scale decades into the future.

Later; disaster struck when I was admiring (playing) with it on the floor when a large piece of chipboard was knocked over onto the model. On removing it; the plane resembled a swatted fly. The wings were intact, but the top wing was now touching the bottom with no gap. The fuselage was splintered and flat. Luckily; the vacformed parts were robust enough to survive. The undercarrage legs were splayed out wide, completing the swatted look.

This was a point of descision for me; was this  setback going to move me away from aeromodelling and onto something less risky, such as stamp collecting? I showed some strength of character and stayed with the hobby.

My brother, who I accused of knocking over the fateful board, a bureau lid, helped draw up replacement parts.

A new fuselage and tail were mated to the original wings, which were patched where the struts were forced through the tissue. The hardest part of the restoration was in digging out the ends of the broken struts from their recesses.

Unfortunately, this time I badly brush painted the model in unthinned Humbrol enamels. This increased the weight, which did not help the 2nd and last flight of the model.

A brand new Telco CO2 motor was installed with lots of downthrust and maybe some side thrust. A test flight was conducted over the short grass of a football pitch. A sharp left spiral dive into the frozen turf destroyed the inner rib bays of the upper and lower wings. This ended the career of the model. I kept the plan and the parts.

I was recently delighted to find the plan and print out of parts on Outerzone.
https://outerzone.co.uk/plan_details.asp?ID=13059
I was supprised to see the same funky green propeller and blue acetate for the windscreen.

Looking back, I am impressed with the kit. The design was simple, with the complex double curvature parts ready made, in plastic. The top deckings was rather thick and heavy; being.l made from the same plastic as the nose cowl, which the propeller nose bearing fitted to.

The balsa, in my particular kit, was nice and light. Important for the fuselage and empenage. The kit captured the important aspects of the full sized plane without the complexities of a strict scale model.

I decided to remake the kit and get it to fly! I will reproduce the attractive yellow scheme from the box photo and have procured some yellow Asuki tissue.

Annoyingly; I have the complete remains of the original model with the exception of the most complex and time consuming to reproduce part. The nose cowl.

Since I will have to make a form for this I decided to replace the three top decking parts as well.

I have rough cut the vac form moulds. These are the most onerous part of the build so I should concentrate on it. Once complete, it will be plane sailing for the rest.

I will power the model with a restored Telco CO2 motor. The original plan suppliment recomended no right thrust and  5 degrees downthrust.

Can anyone confirm this recondation or suggest more reasonable values to start with?
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: TheLurker on Aug 05, 2026, 08:36 AM
Good luck with the archaeology!  :)
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: billdennis747 on Aug 05, 2026, 10:06 PM
That doesn't sound right unless there is some very unusual trim that I don't understand. If the wings are at about +3 degrees and the tail zero, the motor should be about 1 degree down and 1 degree (max) right. Top marks for perseverance!
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 05, 2026, 11:47 PM
Thanks for the advice Bill. I attach the rather suspect instruction sheet from the kit.  I note that the tank is shown immediately behind the motor, where it will maximally effect the CG as the gas runs out. Whilst we unwisely replicated the downthrust; at least we installed the CO2 tank in the front cockpit, under the CG. We also installed a thick ply plate to screw the filler nozzle; as recommended by Telco. I will not be repeating this.

I have now carved an MDF form of the turtle deck and am about to make the first attempts at plunge forming. I am using disposable plastic plates. They used to be widely avaiable at party shops in a wide range of colours, but are now generally replaced with paper. So, I have to order them on line. Annoyingly, the last ones had a diamond pattern embossed on them. Luckily, this vanishes as the plastic reaches the correct forming temperature. Inhave ordered some yellow plates, which I hope will not stand out from the balsa under the tissue.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 05, 2026, 11:49 PM
I am also slightly baffled as to why the Humbrol CO2 motor is not shown mounted inverted, as we did with the Telco.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: billdennis747 on Aug 06, 2026, 09:10 AM
Yes there is no need to invert and it doesn't add much to the appearance!
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: billdennis747 on Aug 06, 2026, 09:16 AM
It might be worth comparing with the excellent Stan Cole plan:
https://outerzone.co.uk/plan_details.asp?ID=3003

It shows 1 1/2 degrees down and 1 right, which sounds right to me.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Pete Fardell on Aug 06, 2026, 03:04 PM
This is a nice project. I wasn't aware of the Humbrol Tiggie. I checked out the other Humbrol plans on Outerzone too, and found the Wasp, which was a very simple stick fuselage rubber job, but with a built up wing. I made one about 50 something years ago after getting the kit as a birthday present. It came with an attractive black and yellow striped sticker saying 'WASP' to stick on the wing. So thanks for bringing back that memory!
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 08, 2026, 11:41 PM
My first attempt at plunge forming the turtle deck. The photo shows my third piece of plastic moulding attempt using a rather roughly finished mould.  The mould is straight tapered in side profile, but curved in planform. I am confident that wetted 1/32" balsa could easily be made to fit. But, I want for the construction to be in keeping with the original.

Luckily, the mould just fits into the flat centre of a 9" disposable plastic party plate.  The plastic is sandwhiched between a 4mm MDF frame and thick card with an aperture with less than 1mm clearance to the male mould. Bulldog clips hold the assembly together whilst it is heated and inch or two from the nozzle of a heat gun set to 300 degrees C. I was annoyed when I bought the plates,  over mail order, that they had a diamond pattern and were not smooth. But, this pattern soon disapeared when the plastic was heated near the required temperature.

Several attempts at heating and plunging were needed. I wondered if oven heating might prove more straightforward.

I had earlier constructed a vacuum form box to fit the 9" plates. This seems unessarary so far, but may be needed when tacking the cowling with its concave contours.

The resulting part has a thickness of only 0.008", whilst one of the original parts was a rather substantial 0.034". It may prove too delicate to withstand being tissue covered. I might perform a trial of the tissue covering to find out, since I have not used Asuka before; in particular over curved sheet surfaces. I can always double or tripple the skin; if nessesary

Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Anyun on Aug 10, 2026, 01:48 AM
Interesting project, I didn't know that Humbrol made stick & tissue models (ok, stick, plastic & tissue..). I like the old silver and maroon paint scheme, even though the paint used didn't help with weight watching  :)
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 10, 2026, 06:31 AM
I have started balsa bashing

I recall that the crash of the original model 4 decades ago caused the curved inboard trailing edges of the upper and lower wings to split along the grain. Whilst a cartwheel on frozen, short grass is always going to break the structure; I have ever since  disliked using a single piece of wood over on a curved part where the end grain is exposed.  I love the elegance and superior strength of laminated parts, even though the glue significantly increases the weight. So, I departed from the plan and am employing laminated parts.

I noted that the inside profile of this trailing edge piece "W6" approximated that of a real of tape. So, i cut around the tape onto 2mm depron to make a circular form. A mylar sheet was added tona foamboard base.

I found some nice fibreous 9 lb/ft^3 1/32" balsa and cut it into 2mm strips. They were soaked in boiling water for quater of an hour or so. Each strip was pulled in tension around an aerosol can lid to impart a curve. They were coated in aliphatic glue and pinned around the circular form.

However careful I am in ensuring each strip lies flat onto the base, I routinely get slightly uneven cross sectional profile due to gaps under some of the strips. So, I cut the strips over thickess and will sand the assembly down to 1/16" (1.5mm) thickness when dry.

I should be a able to get a full set of parts from this single lamination.




Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 18, 2026, 07:40 PM
Bill, thanks for going to the trouble of finding that nice plan showing more moderate thrust angles. I will apply them.

I have cut out the fuselage and empenage from nice, light 1/16" balsa. I plan to inset cross grained inserts into the fin and tailplane to prevent warping. As shown by the masking tape.

I will cover with yellow Asuka tissue. I am not aiming for a perfect finish or to completely fill the wood grain. I have bought some Deluxe Sand n Seal. Does anyone recommend that I apply before or after I apply the tissue?

I will apply a light coating of paint to acieve a uniform colour across the different construction materialz.

Anyun showed the Czech technique of colouring the balsa before covering, in his "Rieseler R III scale 1/25" thread. Much mass is typically added stopping the balsa from showing through the covering; more so than is required to give the general colour.

Does anyone think this sensible to pre-colour the whole fuselage and tail? It kind of defeats the object of weight saving if I paint such a large area.

I am considering a light dusting of Tamiya acrylic from an airbrush. Perhaps, this will help to unify the colour of the balsa/plastic/tissue areas.

Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: ZIP.58 on Aug 18, 2026, 08:51 PM
Good point. Tamiya paints are naturally thin and provide good coverage. Especially when they're stirred well—and all paints should be stirred, of course. I only use Tamiya paints on my models. Plus, they retain their coverage even when further thinned.
Have fun building your great model.

Peter
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 21, 2026, 03:13 AM
Wing trailing edges

I have a clear memory of using too soft a strip for one of the wing trailing edges on the original model. It bend after doping the tissue. This was my introduction to wood selection.

Now, I weigh every sheet of balsa. It is rather overkill for a sports model, but keeping a record of what I used and seeing how it fares on the completed  model, gives me an insite.

I cut a 5mm strip from the edge of a sheet of #7lb/ft3 balsa. I was lucky that I could use the Jim Jones balsa stripper at its maximum width setting.

I had cut from the sheet where it was very opaque when held up to the light. This strip turned out to be  #10lb/ft3 density! The variation within a single sheet is supprising.

I dislike sanding trailing edges on the completed wings as I often damage the ribs and spend much effort repairing the damage.

So, I made a sanding jig consisting of a  length of 1/16" diameter piano wire cyano'd near the edge of a glass shelf from a fridge. It took several attempts to determine the nessesary inset from the edge. An 8mm inset, the width of a Lego brick, yielded the correct chamfer for the strip to match the rear profile of the ribs. The trailing edge of the strip is quite thick: about 1mm. I don't care about achieving a thin trailing edge, but don't want a change in slope at the trailing edge.

Using fresh sandpaper on a hard sanding block made short work of the job. A horrid scratching noise indicated that the sand paper was touching the piano wire and the edge of the glass. Thus, the strip was abraded to the correct profile. The strip was then inverted and a sanding sponge cleaned up the other side of the strip. The yielding surface allowed a little more material to be removed.

I did not induce any noticable bending of the strips due to sanding stresses. If they appear over the next few days then I will soak them in boiling water and weigh them down flat.

I was a bit worried about the stiffness of the sanded sections. So, I performed a simple buckling test by standing each strip vertically on a digital scale and pressing down with my thumb. The reading at which they buckle gave a measure of its stiffness. For indoor duration models; it is critical to employ the combination of the lightest and stiffest woid. But, for this application I only wanted to eliminate the outliers. I found a couple of strips of half the average stiffness and one of double!

So, I cut a strip from a different sheet and and repeated the process untill I found four trailing edges of similar stiffness.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 25, 2026, 12:55 PM
I glued the leading and trailing edges together with the wingtip. I am generally impressed with the design of the kit. However; the straight trailing edge was butt joined to the curved part, as was the outer trailing edge to the tip. I have changed these to long lap joints.I have also added a slot for the lower spar to lock into.

I had pre-shaped the leading edge 1/8" square into a half round profile. I am slightly concerned how well this matches the rub profiles. But, it should have eliminated much sanding after assembly.

Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 26, 2026, 03:50 AM
Ribs cut out from reasonably light balsa. Those at the interplane strut locations, four on the top left, are from denser wood and have lighter 1/16" balsa doublers on each side. It is poor structural design since the doublers terminate just short of the trailing edge. They would look less structurally egregious if from 1/32", but the kit did not employ this wood thickness.

Since they they did not prove to be a weak spot on the original model: I have kept them.

The cabine struts are shown slotted into their ribs. I have departed from the plan and made them and the interplane struts from bass. I had a nightmare when repairing the original model in picking broken balsa struts from their rib sockets, so do not want the parts to be easily damaged. I will glue the struts sparingly with balsa cement, so they can be dismantled with thinners if repairs are needed.

I will next tidy up the spar slots and
stack all the ribs together and sand them to a consistent profile.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 27, 2026, 11:59 PM
The ribs were surrounded in frames made of "Nano Blocks". These are half sized Lego bricks. The photos show before the spar slots were routed and after with 1/16" square inserted. After this; the upper profiles were sanded to be uniform.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: OZPAF on Aug 28, 2026, 03:28 AM
Your use of Nano Lego blocks for temporary jigs is interesting - nice work.

John
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Spiros on Aug 28, 2026, 11:34 AM
It's an excellent idea!

Having only adult children anymore, I'm now looking forward to some grandkids to have the excuse for buying Lego again...... ;D

Thank you for this tip! Excellent!!
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Aug 28, 2026, 07:26 PM
I bought the Nanoblocks to fit between closely spaced Peanut wing ribs, where Lego won't fit. They do not feel as nicely made as Lego and are very fiddly.

I attach photos of the full chord wing ribs with pre shaped leading and trailibng edges. I had allready sanded the front of the ribs down to near the 1/8" leading edge thickness. The rear if the rib profile is over thick and a poor match to the pre shaped trailing edge. I hope that they sand down Ok.

I also show the shorter center section ribs that go over thw top of the trailing edge. Their fronts need sanding down to the leading edge.

The top wing is assenvled with ribs sandwhiched between Lego blocks to ensure that they are straight.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 09, 2026, 05:27 AM
I have made a cowling mould that I am happy with, on my third attempt. Note that I am not trying to reproduce an accurate representation of a real Tiger Moth; but to reproduce the kit part.  Frustratingly; I had lost the original piece so used the photograph of the vacuum formed parts from Outer Zone and the side view from my original plan as references.

My first attempt at a mould consisted of carving a single block of MDF using a washer to form the round area behind then propeller. It looked too blocky.

My third attempt turned the propeller region seperately and attached the lower part on completion. I did not perminaly attach them together, but attached them ,touching, to the plinth. It was a mild revalation to realise that I did not have ton faithfully reproduce the difficult concave transition between the two parts of the mould, under the propeller. But, the plastic will do that anyway (if not vacuumed down too hard)

The parts were taped to a blue foam plinth with a slight undercut which transfered to the plastic to mark the edge of part. The plinth was hollow so that the air intake apertures sucked the plastic into dimples under vacuum.

A vacuum box corresponded to the size of 9" plastic desposible party plates. The latter was bulldog clipped onto a embroidery hoop as a support. A heatgun was set to its maximum of 300 degrees C and heat applied to only the middle of the plate. The plate was held in a gloved hand. Annoyingly; the black plastic plates have a textured pattern. But they proved to be a useful temperature indicator. When they disapeared; the plastic was hot enough. The plate was then placed onto the vacuum box, over the mould. The hot air gun could only heat a small part of the plastic so I had to locally heat parts and smooth them down with an oven gloved finger.

The finish of the test piece is not great, but I am satisfied with the shape.

Disapointingly; I was not able to order yellow plastic plates, but found some 0.5mm yellow plasticard online. This is over double the thickness of the plates , so should be tougher and produce a smoother moulding. I plan to employ 0.25mm white plasticard for the top decking.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 10, 2026, 11:52 PM
I have finished assembling the wings. A change made relative to the plan was adding 1/16" square posts between the upper and lower spars. This should add some resiliance with little weight gain.

I am now procrastinating about sanding them before gluing the panels at the correct dihedral.

That is the last of the woodwork complete.

 I have to finish the last MDF mould for the vacuum form plug for the top of the nose. I dislike carving/sanding MDF; so need to pluck uo coarage to do this job as well.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: ZIP.58 on Sep 11, 2026, 02:39 PM
I was following your post again—and—I had to laugh: Lego bricks!
I've been using these for a long time to keep parts straight. Both the "small" ones and the "Duplo" ones. I filled the ones at the very bottom with lead shot and epoxy resin. That way, the heaviest ones are at the bottom and keep everything from shifting or slipping.
I'll be happy to keep following the report on this model.

Peter
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 12, 2026, 01:37 AM
Thanks Peter,

Lead filled bricks are a good idea. On a different build I have employed Lego bricks containing magnets, onto a steel plate building board.

I recently bought some lead shot which was decanted into small baggies. This proved really useful in holding parts to dry.

A fortuitous thing is that the dihedral called for on the plan is the same as the width of a standard Lego brick. Actually; it is 3/4".

At the moment I use butterfly collecting pins. I can't remember the fancy name for them. They are an inch long and much thinner than dress making pins. They seem more precise and their flexibility seems useful.

But, I love the standard pins in combination with those little black, round pin clamps. A brilliant invention.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 16, 2026, 07:35 PM
Thanks for the useful pin clamp information. It could do with moving to a more findable location.

Back to the model...

CO2 tank location

I am ready to assemble the fuselage and I am thinking about the CO2 tank location.

I note the following examples shown on plans;

1. Humbrol Tiger Moth 19" span (this model)
    Tank immediately behind motor
    very forward of CG
    Protruding out top of nose
    Tank is vertical
    (See post #3)

2. Stan Cole Tiger Moth 18" span
    Tank in front of cabine struts
    Forward of CG
    Approximately 5 degrees from vertical
    Protruding slightly below fuselage

3. Aerographics Tiger Moth 20" span
    Tank half way between motor and front of cabine struts.
    Far forward of CG
    Vertical & fully enclosed.

My original installation:

4. My original installation
     Tank in front cockpit, at CG
     Protruding out of cockpit
     Vertical
     [See photo]

Proposed installations:

5.  Proposed installation with tank fully enclosed     
    Tank at front cabine strut
     Forward of CG
    Tank is fully enclosed
     Tank is 30 degrees from vertical (is this too much?)
     [See photo]

6. Proposed installation with tank vertical and protruding below the fuselage
Tank at front cabine strut
     Forward of CG
     Bottom of tank is exposed
     Tank is vertical
     [See photo]

Questions:

Is the tank being 30 degrees from vertical too much?
Is there an advantage or disadvantage for the tank being forward of the CG?

Option 6 is my favourite so far. What do you think?

Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 17, 2026, 12:40 PM
30 degree angle is not too much, perfectly acceptable.

Regarding position relative to the CG, my personal preference is for the tank to be slightly in front of it, so that when it is full it tends to keep the model from excecive unscale climb and when it empties it allows for a more nose up landing apporach.

This is what I did in my PZL 24 and it is a very good flier. This is what I am also thinking for my d.H. 60 Moth Major currently under construction.

Option 5 for me. Please, no exposed tank (scale nut...)

George

PS. Pinclamp posts split and moved to the techniques board
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 17, 2026, 08:15 PM
Great!, thanks for the feedback George.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 18, 2026, 12:15 AM
Further attempts at Vacuum Forming

This seemed to work best with the 0.25mm HIPS (Plasticard), the 0.5mm yellow did not form well. My attempt at a nose cowl looked like an accident in a custard factory!

In early efforts; the plastic picked up the slightly rough texture of the MDF. So, I gave it a few coats of Sand'n'Seal to smooth it. Unfortunately, this stuck to the hot plastic. 5 coats of mould release wax corrected it. This was fortunate as I did not have any talcom powder and was considering raiding the kitchen and using flour.

The plastic was cut with an inch margin tonthe part and was bulldog clipped into a thin MDF frame. It waz baked in the oven at 180 degrees C for about 5 minutes. When slightly drooping it was taken out and placed over the mould. The  plastic was not floppy enough to drape fully and I employed a hot air gun set to 200 degrees C and a gloved finger to push the plastic around the form. I am disapointed that this is not working better. If I increase the oven temperature then the plastic splits around the clips.

I have just about got parts for the fuselage top decking, but lack a good, complete nose cowl.

Can anyone prove advice?
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: dputt7 on Sep 18, 2026, 05:25 PM
If you increase the area (margin) of the sheet it allows more plastic to be drawn and should mold nicer.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 18, 2026, 07:36 PM
Thanks for the advice, I will give it a go.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 21, 2026, 02:35 AM
I was concerned about the use of vacuum formed polystyrene on the finished model. So I made a trial nose to test the following;

1. How well the plastic attaches using canopy glue

2. How well (unchalked) yellow Asuka covers the different colours of the white plastic and balsa

3. How well chalked Asuka covers the different colours of the white plastic and balsa

4. Does pre-painting the plastic and/or then balsa before tissue covering help?

5. Does the tissue cover the double curvature of the plastic without wrinkles?

6. Does wallpaper paste work Ok. The stuff made from powder and water.

7. Is the plastic stiff enough to withstand the tissue shrinkage?

Conclusions, so far

1. The 0.25mm plastic is stiffer than the soft 1/16" sheet fuselage sides. On one side the plastic glued reasonably flush. The other the plastic was proud. I cut and reglued the plastic. Perhaps the moulding was too wide. A small overhang was Ok since the plastic could be sanded. If underflush then lightweight filler could be used. The canopy glue stuck Ok, but may notnsand well.

More will be answered as I progress...

Reproducing the vacuum formed parts has been a knightmare and has trippeled the build time of this project. I am not even happy with the neatness of the moulds.

The photo shows the nose with aluminium tape holding the rear part of the plastic onto the fuselage side and household DIY lightweight filler applied to the joint.

The inset squares on the balsa side are to simulate the inset strips on the empenage. To find out how prominant they appear under the tissue after sanding.

The nose has been given local areas of lightweight filler and a couple of coats of Sand'n'Seal. This fills then grain nicely.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 21, 2026, 07:16 AM
The test piece has been painted with 50% thinned Tamiya acrylic. The paint does not reduce the contrast between the plastic and balsa. It may even enhance it, due to their differing textures.

I have applied yellow chalk pastel onto some yellow Asuka tissue. I will cover half with chalked and half with unchalked and tissue and see how they compare.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: pb_guy on Sep 21, 2026, 07:22 AM
It looks like it is the grain of the wood that shows through the lighter colour paint, which is acting more like a heavy stain than paint. Perhaps a layer of thin white or yellow tissue overlaying the wood, then sealed and painted might overcome this transparency. But that does add a bit of weight.
ian
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 21, 2026, 01:33 PM
I have now added the yellow Asuka tissue, as Ian suggested. One side is chalked and one is not, as shown in the photos. It was attached with wallpaper paste and is yet to recieve a coat of Pledge acrylic floor polish to seal and waterproof.

Initial conclusions prior to the Pledge coat:

The first conclusion is that the chalk is very subtle. It is hardly worth doing. But I will persist since I have specifically bought chalk for it.

The paint on the white plastic prior to tissue covering significantly helped it match the balsa. Definately worth doing.

Painting the balsa yielded a slightly deeper colour. This can be seen at the nose, in the photos. I am not decided whether to paint the sheet balsa areas.

If I do; I have no idea if it is better to paint the balsa before applying the tissue or to simply paint the covered model as per normal practice. I am not seeking a perfectly opaque finish, but for the plastic, balsa and open framework areas to look uniform.

I will see if the coat of pledge makes the tissue more transparent and changes the conclusion.


Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 22, 2026, 10:46 PM
I have read that doping chalked tissue can give a change in colour. The tissue become more transparent and the colour of the chalk becomesnnore prominant. This did not happen when I sprayed a coat of Pledge. I am very happy with the result.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 23, 2026, 07:34 PM
Success at Last with the Vacuum Formed Parts

I follwed the advice by dputt7 and implimented the following changes:

1. I made 2 new vacuum frame to fit plastic of A5 and A6 size. I could get one A5 and of two A6 from an A4 sheet of Plasticard.

2. I made a new vacuum bed to match the frames and achieved a much better seal than I had achieved with the plastic plates.

3. I added spacers under the moulds so that the vacuum pulls from underneith

I still needed to resort to the hot air gun in one place, but I was happy with the result. I even moulded two parts from a single sheet.

I anticipate needing to rework one of two moulds to fit the plastic to the fuselage better. But, at least I have a reliable process.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 23, 2026, 08:56 PM
You can also try to lift the plugs a bit. 1 cm or so ...

Will pull better but there is one disadvantage. Plastic will pull bellow them so you will have to free them every time you mold.

But they pull better

George
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: OZPAF on Sep 24, 2026, 04:07 AM
That's a good reward for perseverance.

John
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: dputt7 on Sep 24, 2026, 10:51 AM
  Glad it worked, looks good, Well done.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: OZPAF on Sep 25, 2026, 03:54 AM
What did you use for suction? It seems quite powerful - good draw and even pulling into the suction holes.

John
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 25, 2026, 05:27 PM
John,

I used a Shark upright vacuum cleaner. I understand thay a few years ago the Uk limited the power of domestic cleaners. This is one of them. So, not really powerful.

The 0.25mm and 0.50mm Plasticard were cooked in the oven at 200 degrees C for a few minutes until the plastic drooped slightly.

Tim
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: OZPAF on Sep 26, 2026, 03:48 AM
Thanks - it has worked really well.

John
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: gravitywell on Sep 27, 2026, 03:40 AM
Why on Earth would the government limit the suction of a vacuum cleaner?  Thats bizarre.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 27, 2026, 05:03 AM
They limited the power of the motors. Yes, it is really petty.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Andrew D on Sep 27, 2026, 01:09 PM
For what it's worth...

This is my vac form setup.  I don't have many holes, or any seals at all.  The frames are made from aluminium angle and corner brackets from screwfix, and you clamp the material between the flanges with bulldog clips as normal.  The lower angle locates around the bed so the material is essentially flush with the bed when the vacuum is applied.  I heat the material in the oven for a few minutes, quickly get it positioned then bang on the vacuum.  I can plus one on standing off the plug from the surface of the bed. This is a 3D printed plug for the VMC Fokker EV, and produces excellent results.  I got good results too with this set up for the canopies for the VMC Lysander which were pretty large and deep.  On the Fokker plug You can see the stand offs and also some though holes which made the hole locations and "centre pips" very well defined in the final moulding and also allow the full effect of the vacuum at the top of the plug.  Nb the large holes in the plug are to just reduce the amount of material used when 3D printing.  As George said you do get a bit of an undercut with the stand offs, so you have to trim the flash back level with the part to get it out. 
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Andrew D on Sep 27, 2026, 01:13 PM
Quote from: gravitywell on Sep 27, 2026, 03:40 AMWhy on Earth would the government limit the suction of a vacuum cleaner?  Thats bizarre.

Was the EU, with the aim or reducing power consumption.  It's a pain in the UK, as we have a habit of having more wall to wall carpeting that require a bit more ooomph than on the continent where tend to go with hard floors more...
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Sep 27, 2026, 09:36 PM
Thanks for the information about your vacuum setup Andrew.

Tim
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Oct 04, 2026, 05:32 AM
This post feels like a confession of a dirty secret. I have only once before resorted to using DIY filler on a model and never on a wing.

I have been having an awfully tedious time sanding the wings.

I put some effort into pre-sanding the leading and trailing edges and checking their profiles against the ribs, before assembly. But still found problems.

I cut out a card profile board as a reference. This is rather overkill and I certainly am not concerned about accurately reproducing whatever wing section the kit specified. But, the photo below shows how the profile.board helped to highlight the step between the rib and the leading edge.

Screenshot_20261004_031308_Photos (1).jpg

I ended up adding shims of balsa:
Screenshot_20261004_031410_Photos (1).jpg

And in particularly bad areas I applied DIY store lightweight filler (shown before sanding)
Screenshot_20261004_031515_Files by Google (2).jpg

At least the trailing edge matched well to the sanded rib profile.
Screenshot_20261004_032659_Files by Google (1).jpg
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Oct 04, 2026, 04:47 PM
I have glued the wings together with balsa cement (thinned Duco). The root ribs were precoated a couple of times before the final application.

This should allow me to seperate them, with acetone, if a repair or replacement is needed. The 19mm tip dihedral specified in the plan corresponded exactly to the width of Lego bricks. I used tape under the joints and small baggies of lead shot to hold the wing panels down without warps.

Final shaping of the centre section will follow; so that the structure matches each panel
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Oct 11, 2026, 03:18 PM
The fuselage has glued together not straight. This is disapointing; considering the tab and slot construction. The sides were of similar stiffness, so that was not the cause. I have to live with it or scrap the fuselage. I chose the former.

At least I can try to get the motor thrustline, wings and tail in their correct orientations to each other.

I layed the fuselage on foamboard and marked the centreline as best I could. The centre of the nose was not near to the pencil mark. Oh well!

I marked 2 degrees sidethrust bisecting the centreline and used a card shape attached to the engine firewall to eyeball thenalignment.

I used a card jig resting on the fuselage botttom and the back of the firewall to set the downthrust.

Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Oct 12, 2026, 10:12 PM
The three canted and uncanted ribs forming the joint between the centre section and each wing panel lack the sharp crease where the dihedral begins.

So, I added tape at this point, as a guide, and made a sanding block to the exact width of the centre section. Unfortunately, more balsa shims and filler was required.

I am disapointed with the amount of rework nessesary to such a simple structure. I hope that this is rewarded with a covering that is smooth and wrinkle free.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Oct 14, 2026, 12:18 AM
I have installed a refurbished Telco.

I need to check that it runs before gluing the top decking on the nose. Unfortunatley, my large soda stream bottle is empty and I understand that the bottle it uses is superced (I have not flown CO2 for a long time). So, I need to get a friend to fill thw tank to test the motor.

The first photo shows the hole in the bottom of the firewall through which the  cylinder head and pipework are threaded before attaching to the cylinder head.
Screenshot_20261013_213020_Files by Google (1).jpg

The send photo shows the inclinded tank installation. The filler nozzle will protrude out of the front cockpit.

Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: billdennis747 on Oct 14, 2026, 10:03 AM
Where I am, Lakeland stocks both types of bottle.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Squirrelnet on Oct 14, 2026, 10:27 AM
QuoteUnfortunatley, my large soda stream bottle is empty and I understand that the bottle it uses is superced (I have not flown CO2 for a long time). So, I need to get a friend to fill thw tank to test the motor.

I use Grabner refils in Abergavenny they can fill all types of bottles including the ones with the old thread for about £12 + post (https://grabner.co.uk)
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Oct 14, 2026, 06:45 PM
Thanks for the recommendations gents. I am very happy to not have to change my charger.

Squirrelnet; I have been reading your helpful vacuum forming article from the August 2021 Aeromodeller.

My fuselage has not turned out exactly the shape as the plan intended, so I have to make a new rear decking mould. I will use balsa, rather than MDF, this time. Since it is easier to work.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Oct 14, 2026, 07:41 PM
The cowl was formed from the 0.5mm yellow plasticard. I cyano'd a couple of rings of the same plastic to reinforce the hole for the propeller. A Sharpy marker made a convenient mandrel tonline them up.

I intend for the hex throttle nut of the Telco motor to protrude from the cowl.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Squirrelnet on Oct 15, 2026, 09:55 AM
QuoteSquirrelnet; I have been reading your helpful vacuum forming article from the August 2021 Aeromodeller.

Thanks Tim , great to hear it is of use. Nice looking cowling   ;D
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Nov 01, 2026, 06:59 PM
Following a trial fit of the cowl; it turns out that I needed 3mm of packing between the motor and the firewall to ensure that the Telco throttle nut could be turned.
Screenshot_20261101_165538_Photos (1).jpg


I soldered two nuts to some piano wire to make a captive nut arrangment.
Screenshot_20261101_165249_Photos (1).jpg
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Nov 08, 2026, 02:03 AM
I cannot resist jumping ahead and posting some uncovered photos. The airframe with motor weighs 47g. If no ballast is required then it should be around 50g covered.

The plan specifies a mass of 53g. I presume that this is with rubber since a wing loading is given and it makes sense to me that this must be based on flying weight (with rubber). I recall that the kit included 4 strands of 1/16" rubber, loop length equal to the propeller to peg of 9 inches. This is about 3g.

The Telco weighs about 15g so my (anticipated) 35g covered airframe is comfortably under this. But, this could change if noseweight is needed.

I flatter myself that my wood selection and building skill contribute to the majority of the saving. About 4g saving was achieved using thinner plastic for the vacuum formed parts.

The partial remains of my original model weigh 46g, with a heavy coat of brushed Humbrol enamel. This matches the kit specifications well.

The plan gives a wing area of 7.5g/dm2 and a wing loading of 7g/dm2

My version should has a loading of 6.7g/dm2, which is 0.43g/inch2. My rule of thumb is that under 0.5 g/inch2 is pretty good.

So, I am pretty happy with my new model mass.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: dputt7 on Nov 08, 2026, 07:36 AM
Well done, it looks like your careful attention to the weight of components will pay off.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: TheLurker on Nov 08, 2026, 09:13 AM
Lovely job.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Andrew D on Nov 08, 2026, 01:04 PM
Looks great!  :)
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Spiros on Nov 08, 2026, 01:35 PM
Beautiful result!! Bravo
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: ZIP.58 on Nov 08, 2026, 03:18 PM
Great—that'll make for a model that flies really well. The way you're paying attention to the weight, it's bound to turn out that way.
Keep enjoying the build.

Peter
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Nov 10, 2026, 09:27 PM
I attach a table of weights for the different materials that I tried to make the vacuum formed parts. I include the original nose top decking. I estimated the mass of the other kit mouldings by scaling from the new parts. Estimated weights are given in square brackets.

I could not measure the thickness of the black plastic party plate because it had a dimpled surface. Scaling its thickess from the Plasticard, I estimate it to 0.18mm thick. It formed easily, but the material became too thin in places and was damaged on removal. With the exeption of the nose cowl, the thinnest plastic parts would have been strong enough on the model and would have saved a lot of weight, being only 1.7g in total.

The 0.25mm thick plastic parts weighed 2.2g but were also  damaged on removal and lead me to use the thicker 0.50mm yellow plasticard. The total mass of all the yellow parts seemed excessive at 3.5g, but was less than half of my estimation of the original kit plastic. This was a whopping 7.7g! It is not just the weight itself that is important. It is parts location relative to the centre of gravity. I could easily imagine the kits 3.8g rear fuselage decking nessesitating 10g of noseweight!

In am not sure of orignial thickness of the kit parts but measureed 0.034" on the end of a part. Since  the plastic does not increase thickness in forming: maybe 1mm was used. Maybe the thick plastic was more reliable forming. I found that thicker material less likely to split on removal from the moulds.

In hindsight; the vacuum formed moulds and parts doubled the time and effort taken to build the kit. It would have been easier and lighter to use 1/32" sheet on the fuselage top decking, as shown on the outzone plan. But, I am please to have replicated the most notible part of the kit.

For the kit; the pre-formed parts were a great way of reducing the build time and complexity.

Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Raggedflyer on Nov 11, 2026, 09:53 AM
When I eyeball the 0.25 / 0.5 mm columns the weights of the cowl, cockpit and rear items scale in proportion to the thickness. The nose item  at 0.8 g / 0.84 g is nearly the same for both thicknesses which seems odd?
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Nov 11, 2026, 10:53 PM
Hi Raggedflyer,

I an impressed that anyone had a close look at the data! I like to post information here as it forces me to make it understandable, in anticipation that I might review it at a later date. I don't have a strong expectation that someone will review it in detail. But, I am please if anyone does so.

I have had a second go at weighing the parts. The nose top data is now more consistent. I have included some others I found on my work bench. This gives an idea of the repeatability of those parts. However, some which split on removal from the mould were not carefully trimmed.

Cheers


Tim
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Nov 11, 2026, 11:15 PM
I am working on one of the worst jobs of building a biplane; rigging the wings.

I made a change to the plan in pinning as well as gluing the cabine struts to the fuselage. I want a positive location for the struts in case a later repair is needed. I employed a 0.8mm carbon rod traversing the fuselage, just behing the CO2 tank, penetrating plastic pin clamps glued to the inside of the fuselage.

I carefully set the location of the front pins from the plan. I checked their symmetry using a foamboard rigging base with the centreline and spanwise lines marked.

I made the mistake of serting the rear pin location by installing the struts and pricking through the holes in the rear struts.  This introduced a fore/aft aymmetry of over a 1mm between port and starboard sides. The photo shows that aft strut rods are nowhere near aligned. Indeed, a single rod would not go through both sides!
Screenshot_20261111_205821_Photos (1).jpg

So, I will have to cut away one of the plastic pin clamps and reglue it.  I will position the top wing before I do so.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: OZPAF on Nov 12, 2026, 02:06 AM
It's interesting to see how much weight you have saved with your vacuum formed alternatives.

John
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Nigel_M on Nov 12, 2026, 08:49 PM
Using the pin clamps as a reinforcing for carbon is a great idea. I have some of the black ones but could do with a source of spares. Anyone any idea where they might be obtained now?
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Jmk89 on Nov 12, 2026, 09:10 PM
Quote from: Nigel_M on Nov 12, 2026, 08:49 PMUsing the pin clamps as a reinforcing for carbon is a great idea. I have some of the black ones but could do with a source of spares. Anyone any idea where they might be obtained now?
Peck Polymers (Wind-it-up Enterprises) lists them but they seem to be out of stock at the moment:
https://www.wind-it-up.com/collections/tools/products/pin-clamps?variant=32423029538901
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Nov 13, 2026, 03:36 AM
I made a foamboard jig for rigging the model. This seems rather overkill, but I enjoy making complex jigs and boxes out of foamboard. Also, the fuselage is not symmetric and care is needed to try to get the motor thrustline in the correct orientation to the wings and tail. At least the fuselage is the correct colour to match its banana shape!

I anticipate needing the jig in case of future repairs. The jig will support the model in its transport/storage box. The box will keep the wreckage of the original model,  along with all the moulding jigs  to keep everything in one place.

A foamboard plinth was made with the centre section of the lower wing lying flat and 90 degrees to the fuselage centreline. The fuselage was supported at the correct incidence. Slots allowed the undercarrage to penetrate the plinth. Supports are added to ensure that the tailplane is parallel to the plinth, thus with the wings, when it is glued on.

I photocopied the wing rigging templates from the plan and glued them to some foamboard. These are removeable from the base to allow the model to be held or removed.

Weirdly; I had to extend the upper wing slots forward 4mm, increasing the stagger. I am not concerned if the location of the top wing is a little forward, as long as the incidence is accurate and the wings are square to the centreline. The upper and lower wings are set at the same incidence. Nice and simple.

A removeable card jig rests on the fuselage cockpit openings to set the centre section incidence. I was pleased that the relocated rear cabine strut pin made the wing sit in aligment. Also, that the top wing naturally sits on the centre and tip supports without having to be held. I hope that this remains the case after covering and shrinking the wings i.e. that I do not introduce any warps.

The carbine struts did not need adjusting in length to penetrate their sockets in the upper wing centre section. But, I may have to make longer rear interplane struts. The intention is that the struts do not rest on the top/bottom of their sockets,  but float and will be held with balsa cement.
Title: Re: Humbrol Tiger Moth
Post by: Piecost on Nov 17, 2026, 09:46 PM
I am covering the model in yellow Asuka tissue. I am chalking the tissue rather than painting it. I am not painting the balsa before covering.

I taped the sheet of tissue to a sheet of glass, rough side up. I sanded a Cadmium Yellow Faber-Castell Soft Pastell and rubbed the powder into the surface with a tissue.

I used chalked tissue on my previous peanut model and could not detect an increase in mass. So, I carefully weighed the tissue before and after application.

I used about 5mm of the rectangular bar, about 0.65g which increased the wieght of the tissue by 0.22g. So, about a third is absorbed. This increased the tissue from 13.9 gsm to about 14.8 gsm.