HPA

General Forum => In the Work Shop => Topic started by: Piecost on Aug 18, 2026, 06:39 PM

Title: Comparison of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Aug 18, 2026, 06:39 PM
This thread summarises some experiments performed on different types of tissue sealed with acrylic and with wallpaper paste. It is inspired by Anyun's build thread, which I was starting to hijack :

Rieseler R III scale 1/25
https://hpa.aeromodelling.gr/index.php?topic=394.0

Anyun described using a type of Japanese tissue which is lighter than that available from aeromodelling suppliers. It is obtainable from fine art or book restoration specialists and can be very expensive. It is known as Tengujo Kashmir. I have obtained "Kozo Shika", which I hope is the same stuff. Either way, it was the only type that I could obtain the the UK. The postage was significant; a third of the cost. I was too frightened to even find out international postage rates for overseas suppliers.

The Czech aeromodelling forum is a constant source of inspiration and information, but Google translate struggles with hobby specific words. So, my understanding remained rather sketchy. I had actually bought samples of the tissue and the Czech wallpaper paste, a few years ago, but didn't know what to do with them! Anyun's thread has motivated me into action.

Link to Robert Pajas page describing different tissues:
https://www.minimakety.cz/howto/2009/Potah/index.php

Anyun is following Czech practice of using a very porous tissue and applying multiple coats of wallpaper paste to form an inpervious skin.

I bought two different mass of "Conservation Kozo Shika" and attached samples to 100mm x 100mm balsa frames.

The "9gsm" tissue measured  9.1gsm
The "4gsm" tissue meadured  3.5gsm

I sprayed 1 coat of unthinned Pledge Multi-Surface (acrylic) wax, instead of dope. This was nessesary to bind the fibres together before applying the wallpaper paste. Despite this; the fibres of the lightest sample started to pull appart when the paste was being brushed on.

I applied 5 coats of Metylan wallpaper paste, starting in a ratio of 0.57g of powder to 20ml of water. This was following the stronger mix ratio stated on the packet. As Anyun advised; more water was added to the mixture for subsequent coats to retain the consistancy. It's consistancy was slightly more runny than liquid honey. Liberal coats were applied with the softest brush that I could find.

A careful inspection of the surface was required to ensure that all the pores were filled. Perhaps further dabs of paste should be applied over pourous regions, rather than coating the whole surface.

Conclusions

The 3.5gsm tissue was easy to handle and to glue to the frame when dry. But is very delicate when damp and would be challenging in covering double curvature areas such as wingtips. It resembles a mesh/net more than a solid surface and 5 coats of paste sealed in some areas, but was not enough in others. The fibres are easily pulled apart when brushing and have caused slackness in some areas.  It is not practical for my skill level.

The 9gsm was really easy to use dry. Care would be needed when damp. I have not tried it on curved surfaces such as  wingtips. The paste coating worked well. The covering is drum tight and resembles doped Esaki. However, in my limoted experience, it does not offer a weight saving over other aeromodelling tissues.

Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Aug 18, 2026, 07:10 PM
Unfortunately; I could not obtain the 6gsm version of Kozo Shika. I anticipate that when filled that it will be significanty lighter than the aeromodelling tissues without the drawbacks of the 4gsm sample.

It has been successfully used by Jirka Pavlicek on his fanstastic Zlin build:
https://hpa.aeromodelling.gr/index.php?topic=273.15

I was intriged by the finished mass per area of these tissues compared to more readily available, lightweight, aeromodelling tissues.

So, I made further samples of different tissues from my stocks.

I attach a table giving the mass/area of the untreated and treated tissues. They are ordered from lightest to heaviest of the finished samples.

I water sprayed the samples to taughten, then sprayed a single coat of Pledge.
This was applied to all samples at the same time using an airbrush. Each sample was then, in-turn, and sprayed induvidually until it was sufficently wetted.

Conclusion

The following only considers mass and a cursory look at the surface porousity and smoothnes. Other critical items such as, wet strength and shrinkage are not considered.

The table of weights of the coated tissue should be taken with some skeptasism. I do not know how repeatable the results are. So, the results should be taken to indicate general trends only. Other poeple might get different results.

The 4gsm Kozo was the lightest, but not useable . The tissue disintegrated in places; slack and porous. Other areas quite useable.

I was supprised that thr 9gsm Kozo was one of the lightest tissues but that the wallpaper paste, needed to seal its pores, pushed the total weight up to more than many conventional aeromodelling tissues. Perhaps, I am applying the coats too heavily.  Do more numerous, thinner, coats seal it better? My conclusion has to be that the 9gsm Kozo offers no advantage in finished weight. It is nice though and I may use it on my next model. This increases my desire to obtain some 6gsm Kozo, which I feel will be lighter.

The Dilly tissue was similar in uncoated mass to Esaki, but was significantly lighter after 1 coat of Pledge. It's surface is very smooth.

I think of Esaki as the benchmark. It doesn't really need coating to produce an air-tight surface. It took a little more mass of Pledge than the Dilly. Perhaps, I over-did it.

The Lense Tissue (the stuff used for cleaning glasses) was too porous and really needs some coats of wallpaper paste to seal it. This would increase its mass. I don't consider it useful for our purposes.

The Gampi was very similar to Esaki, a good sustitute. But, I have not tried it on curved surfaces.

The yellow Asuka was a little heavier than Easki and took more Pledge. But, again, felt like a good substitute. It is slighty heavier than Dilly and Gampi, but comes in a limited selection of colours.

The Balsa Cabin tissue was heavier and took more Pledge. Whilst it was sealed; it's surface was still blotchy, like it had not been sufficently wetted. The increased mass would be more suitable to models larger than peanuts. Again, it.comes in colourz.

Using Solvite wallpaper border adhesive was quite heavy at about 0.2g. It was not accounted for in the weight comparion table. This is heavy relative to coating on the tissue. Dope and thinners might be lighter.

Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Prosper on Aug 21, 2026, 03:48 PM
Many thanks for this informative work, Tim.

Stephen.
Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: OZPAF on Aug 23, 2026, 04:20 AM
I agree - thanks for the detailed test and report.

John
Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Spiros (Spyros) on Aug 23, 2026, 09:42 AM
Excellent presentation.

Thank you very much!
Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Oct 24, 2026, 08:11 PM
I finally obtained some 6gsm Conservation Kozo Shika, which actually weighed 5.4 gsm.

This felt similar to use as the 9 gsm, rather than the delicate 4 gsm. Care was needed is dintinguishing the 6 and 9 gsm tissues.

I applied the same process as before; gluing to a balsa frame. Not water shrinking , but spraying with Pledge acrylic floor wax to bind the fibres togther to withstand the brushed on sealant coats. In hindsight; It was a big mistake to use water based pledge to bind the fibres since I was using water based sealing coats. They softened the binding and allowed the fibres to move, forming holes.

I should have used the cellulose based Zapon varnish that I used on the pre-coated tissues in the sealing foam thread:

https://hpa.aeromodelling.gr/index.php?topic=419.0

So, we should not write-off those samples which were damaged, but concentrate on their final masses.

I tried the following sealung coats:
 9.  CKS 5.4gsm  1 coat of Pledge airbrushed + 1 coat of Metylan brushed
10. CKS 5.4gsm 1 coat of Pledge airbrushed + 1 coat of Pledge brushed
11.  CKS 5.4gsm 1 coat of Pledge airbrushed + 1 coat of Sand'N'Seal brushed

I did not employ multiple coats for any of the samples since items 9 and 11 were damaged by brushing.

Item 9 was badly damaged by brushing with Metylan: with large holes, waves and slackness.
It was not useable, by only weighed 12.9 gsm.

Item 10 using a brushed coat of Pledge  gave a useable surface, with only a few pin holes. The brushing did not damage it and it came in at only 12.7 gsm. This was a big success. It came out lighter than any of the coated tissues in the first  tests and is similar to untreated Esaki.

I don't know why the brushed coat of Pledge did not prevent the first airbushed coat from holding the fibres together. For a model; I would add a 2nd brushed coat of Pledge to fully seal the holes, which would add another 2 gsm.

Item 11 was much better than 9, but feature regions with holes. Elsewhere, it was sealed but with small waves. It weighed a massive 27.1 gsm due to the Sand'N'Seal. Much heavier than any of the previous tests. I am not sure why it is such.
Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Oct 25, 2026, 05:48 PM
Before I realised the error in using a water based initial coat to hold the fibres together; I tried to repeat the Metylan test. Test 9 used Metylan but caused slackness and holes in the tissue. The new test:

12.  CKS 5.4gsm  1 coat of Pledge airbrushed + 5 full coats of Metylan brushed and one partial coat to fill pin holes.

I airbrushed Pledge generiously until the tissue was wetted and tiny beads of liquid formed. This added 5gsm, doubling the weight of the tissue!
Screenshot_20261023_160344_Files by Google (1).jpg

I trimmed the soft, flat brush to reduce its thickess, so reducing the force applied to the tissue.
Screenshot_20261023_174520_Photos (1).jpg

I took much more care in brushing the Metylan lightly, not bending the brush bristles much. This was sucessfull.

I applied 5 full coats of Metylan and then dabbed the pin holes with additional Metylan using a pointed brush. This did not fully eliminate the pores and more would have to be done.

The finish was drum tight and smooth and came out at 16.5 gsm.

It has worked well and has demonstrated the Czech technique. But, I prefer using Pledge as it was significantly lighter, ar 12.7 gsm and less coats were required. However, the latter is slightly less smooth.

Screenshot_20261025_153452_Files by Google (1).jpg
Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Nov 06, 2026, 07:13 PM
A graph of the weight gain for test 12. It is notable how much the initial airbrushed coat of Pledge adds relative to each brushed coat Metylan. The latter added so little weight with each coat that it was within the range of error of the scales. Some coats even registered a weight reduction.
Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Nov 06, 2026, 07:15 PM
A summary of the tests.
Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Nov 06, 2026, 07:22 PM
I dug out my tins of cellulose dope from the garage. One of them has not withstood the rigours of time so well. I have not plucked uo the courage to open the others.
Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Anyun on Nov 12, 2026, 11:57 PM
Interesting tests of different techniques! Yes, a soft brush is essential to avoid damaging the tissue. However, it's much easier to work with an actual wing etc than the large panels in your tests, as the areas of unsupported tissue are much smaller.

I have also tried an acrylic floor wax (think it was Pledge) but found that although it was usable there were always quite a lot of pores remaining, even after several applications. I guess the particular type is important. It could however be used on ordinary jap tissue as a substitute for dope.
Title: Re: Comparion of Coated Tissues
Post by: Anyun on Nov 13, 2026, 12:11 AM
One of your cans have definitely passed its best-before date!

I should also add that zapon lacquer (=cellulose lacquer) in itself does not have the ability to cover the pores in these lightweight tissues, but builds up weight quickly. One or two coats applied first does however make the tissue much more resilient when applying the metylan.
Title: Re: Comparison of Coated Tissues
Post by: OZPAF on Nov 13, 2026, 01:09 AM
As the problem with these lightweight tissues is largely a matter of porosity I'm wondering if a laminate of 2 layers (Cross ply) may require less filler than a single layer and be towards the lightest end of your tests.

John

Title: Re: Comparison of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Nov 13, 2026, 02:44 AM
Ozpaf,

Laminating the lighter tissue is a thought, but it would be more straightforward to simply use a heavier version of the same. The Kozo Shika comes in a wide range of masses. I presume that they use the same fibres, buy vary their density.

I had wondered about using a very light plastic film under a light tissue. Many people recomment it for standard weight tissue. I have not tried it myself.

I can see the advantage in reducing the mass of dope to seal tissue. But, what is the advantage over using mylar on its own?

Title: Re: Comparison of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Nov 13, 2026, 02:57 AM
Anyun, thanks for the advice. The part about the size of the unsupported tissue is especially interesting.

I have replaced using dope and thinners with Pledge on my last couple of models. The smell is much more compatable with my family.

I airbrushed two coats of unthinned Pledge onto white Esaki. I did not carefully look for porosity. This may have become visible if I painted the tissue rather than using coloured chalk.
Title: Re: Comparison of Coated Tissues
Post by: cvasec on Nov 13, 2026, 11:58 AM
The Mylar does not add any torsional rigidity but tissue does.
Ron
Title: Re: Comparison of Coated Tissues
Post by: Piecost on Nov 13, 2026, 01:42 PM
Thanks Ron

Tim