HPA

Scale Free Flight Forum => Scale, Indoor (F4D, F4E, Kitscale) => Topic started by: g_kandylakis on Sep 07, 2026, 02:44 PM

Title: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 07, 2026, 02:44 PM
I have (better, had) a few principles in my modelling career. One was not to build the same model again in different sizes. There are plenty of subjects out there waiting to be modelled. Well, that went down the drain.

My PZL 24 CO2 model has had a good flying life, probably the best compared to other models of mine. But showing up again at an event with it was a cause for discomfort. I needed a replacement.

With only three months to go (now only two) for the coming IIFI I made the wild thought of repeating the build of last year, my Moth Major peanut, only slightly larger. The model flies nicely, the plan and documentation are already there, it i very simple to enlarge everything slightly and end up with a new entry for CO2.

Whether this works out in the end remains to be seen, so the PZL will be ready as a back up.

The model will be at 1/20 scale, about 46 cm wing span, which makes it a rather small model. This causes some questions regarding powerplant. I want to use again a Brown motor but they are a bit too large and powerful for such a small model. Which is ok, as long as they can fit inside the cowl. It is tight but looks feasible.

Work has started on the wings, one is completely finished, the other needs sanding and the other two need to be glued together.

So, not much to show yet. Starting with the wingtip laminations.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 07, 2026, 02:45 PM
a mix of old and new, outline templates for the peanut version, riblets for the CO2 one and wing construction beginings.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 07, 2026, 02:46 PM
And we have a wing, 3 more to go.

And size comparison with the finished peanut version.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 13, 2026, 01:40 PM
Work continues with a rather slow pace, exactly two months before IIFI where it is supposed to fly.

Working on the 3rd wing panel. Also started the fuelage sides. When there are significan curves for the longerons, I always laminate them to achieve a stress free structure.

Compared to my peanut version of one year ago, I am one month behind.

Positive:
All, or at least most of the engineering and design work is done, so I only rescale and print what I need.

Negative:
A CO2 model is slightly more complicated than a rubber powered one, so it might take some extra time.

We'll see...

George
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: TheLurker on Sep 13, 2026, 02:40 PM
Quote from: g_kandylakis on Sep 13, 2026, 01:40 PM....it might take some extra time.
George
Ahh, just bunk off work.  I'm sure they'll understand that that "toy aeroplanes" are far more important than anything else.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: Squirrelnet on Sep 13, 2026, 08:25 PM
Great project George, watching this with great interest. I'm a bit of a DH60 fan too so the thought of a CO2 Moth Major is exciting. Will this be the same scheme as your peanut one ?
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 14, 2026, 12:17 AM
Hi Chris,

Glad you like it. Yes, exactly the same, I admit with slight shame...

George
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: marcin_pl on Sep 14, 2026, 01:31 PM
George,

Do you cut ribs one by one using a single template or stack them and sand all together?
How do you cut openings for internal spars?

Marcin
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 14, 2026, 01:56 PM
Hi Marcin,

One by one.
Two templates, 0.6mm plywood. Individual balsa piece in between.
Sharp razor blade cuts easily along the template, minimal sanding required, very light so the templates are not worn in the end.

Slots are made with very sharp #11 blade or home made tools with sharp steel carbon blades, finished with small square diamond files.

I have pictures somewhere. Here in our Greek forum:
https://www.aeromodelling.gr/ForumS/index.php?topic=58377.msg330018#msg330018

I stopped block sanding years ago for a variety of reasons.

I like my wings to be built like the original, so the spar has to be centrally located. So holes are necessary for the spars, very difficult to achieve with a block. The same goes for lightening holes.
https://www.aeromodelling.gr/ForumS/index.php?topic=59547.msg341232#msg341232

These threads existed in the old HPA, now they are gone...

Also the ribs are not exactly the same, from end to center to end. They might move during sanding or you might oversand the template as well.

Excessive maybe but that is how I like it.

George
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 17, 2026, 12:57 PM
Still battling with the third wing panel, but I did make some progress with the fuselage.

Both sides done and as I write this, 50% of the box completed.

Here is something simple one might find interesting.

I always pay attention when building a fuselage side to have wood of equal thickness, so that the second side can be built on the same "height" or "plane". Sometimes this is not possible.

So, a slight sanding of the first side is necessary, to make everything smooth and even.

I was afraid I might overdo it or sand inconsistently this time, so I added two spacers on my sanding block, to prevent oversanding. Proved quite successful, I got exactly 2,0mm everywhere and a very smooth side.

Did the same with the second side after they were separated.

Less than two months to go now

George
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: TheLurker on Sep 17, 2026, 07:50 PM
That sanding block idea is sneaky.  I like it.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: nickhawk on Sep 20, 2026, 12:48 PM
Yes I agree if only George would make it adjustable by micrometer gauges and electric.....
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 25, 2026, 01:55 AM
That is a good idea Nick, you know my fondness for micrometers...

Progress since my last posts:

Basic fuselage box almost done

This is how a proper workbench looks like. Or should look like...

Quick put-together to get an idea of the 1/20 scale size.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 25, 2026, 02:01 AM
With 0,7mm thick (thin?) ribs, they do get wobly during assembly until they are permanently glued to the spars and leading edge. I exaggerated the missalignment for that picture (internal joke).

Nose slowly coming to shape. CO2 engine installation first mock-up. In order to make the complete power unit removable the top cowl decking will have to be made removable too, same as the nose front.

Current status of the fuselage

And four wing panels roughly done, in varying levels of sanding and finishing. Ailerons on bottom wings only. Were simply painted in the peanut version, separate parts here.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: Piecost on Sep 25, 2026, 05:38 PM
Lovely light wing structure. Will you be adding stiffening, such as gussets, around the ailerons to prevent wrinkles
in the covering?
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 25, 2026, 05:45 PM
thanks...

Yes, but not gussets. Internal reinforcements.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: ZIP.58 on Sep 26, 2026, 03:57 PM
What do you use for these internal reinforcements?
Carbon fiber?

Peter
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 27, 2026, 12:54 AM
Hi Peter,

I imagine you are talking about the last picture. IT is the wing of my Sopwith Batboat.

Here is a picture of the top center section of same.

I would not call them reinforcements although that is their purpose. They are part of the spars which are a sandwich of carbon strips top and bottom CAed to a balsa core.

Initial dimension of the carbon strips is 3,0x0,15mm. Final width depends on the required spar width.

They add quite a lot of stifness and some eweight of course.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Oct 10, 2026, 12:09 AM
The Moth Major has also progressed a bit. I hit an obstacle with the fuselage, it needs some intense building and improvising to install the CO2 equipment and I am not feeling up to it at the moment, so I thought I 'd finish the tail instead and thereby the complete wooden structure.

Frames are 1,5mm thick, laminated outlines 3x0,5mm. Some rather sharp curves so plenty of soaking.

Stab was done in two pieces, glued together in the middle.
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Oct 10, 2026, 12:15 AM
When the basic frame was finished, I added extra pieces, 1mm thick, on either side, to make a symmetrical airfoil section, 3,5mm in the middle, 1,5mm at the outlines.

In the first pictures the frame is still on the building board, so only the left side could be added. When dry, the other side was also glued.

Other two pictures show the finished sanded result. Spiros asked how to do this, so I am showing it for him...

The horizontal tail is under construction now.

Chances for completion before 12th November are very slim now but I am building on anyway. I guess it will be the PZL 24 again for IIFI...

George

Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: g_kandylakis on Nov 10, 2026, 10:58 PM
And of course this project got stalled...

Horizontal tail still on the building board, gave up on rushing it for IIFI quite some time ago.

But it should be ready for 2028.

PZL 24 once again for me, repaired after the summer UK adventure.
Currently enroute somewhere in Slovenia in nickhawk's car.

George
Title: Re: Moth Major for CO2
Post by: billdennis747 on Nov 10, 2026, 11:26 PM
Hi George. That's how I build my tail surfaces now. I came across the method on Earl Stahl's designs; they always stay warp-free.