HPA

Scale Free Flight Forum => Peanut Scale => Topic started by: MockwingF on Sep 13, 2026, 02:20 PM

Title: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Sep 13, 2026, 02:20 PM
After building a few simple free-flight models, I have now started my first Peanut Scale project. I chose the BD-4 based on a plan by Bill Hannan.

Although I am generally staying close to the original plan, I have made a few minor modifications in certain areas. These are not major structural changes, but rather small adjustments that give me greater confidence in terms of stability, alignment, and ease of construction.

So far, the wing, horizontal stabilizer, and vertical fin structures are complete. Construction has gone smoothly, and the characteristic lines of the BD-4 are already becoming recognizable.

I am currently working on the fuselage, which is the next major stage of the build. Up to this point, the model has been great fun to build, and I am looking forward to seeing how the project develops.

Scale building is proving to be a real challenge. Scale accuracy and low weight are often in direct conflict with each other, so every construction detail becomes a compromise. It is a constant balancing act between adding detail and keeping the model light enough to remain a practical flyer.

I'm curious to see how the project progresses from here.

To be continued...

Markus


Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 13, 2026, 02:41 PM
Hi Markus,

A very good choice...

Two questions, which plan are you using?
The original from the Peanut Power book or the revised one?

Second, why did you leave the nose section from the side panels? It is much easier if you add them flat now.

George
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Sep 13, 2026, 02:54 PM
Hi George,

the suggestion to build the BD-4 as my first Peanut Scale model came from Christian, a German scale builder, after my visit to the IFI 2025.

I am using the revised plan from this forum. However, before I joined the forum, I had already drawn my own plan because I could not make a decent copy from the book without taking the book apart. Therefore, I am basically building from the original plan, while incorporating some of the revisions such as the longer motor and the adjustable tailplane.

Regarding the nose section, I am currently working on it and plan to add most of it flat, as you suggest. I am simply not at that stage yet. In addition, my chosen prototype has a slightly different nose shape and a distinctive cooling slot, so I am still experimenting a bit to find a solution that captures those features.

Thanks for the advice!
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: dputt7 on Sep 14, 2026, 09:03 AM
   That's a very pretty aircraft to model, hope all goes well.
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Sep 20, 2026, 08:01 PM
Many thanks for your interest!

Attached is my latest build progress. The fuselage side frames are now completed, and I have started working on the nose block.

Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Spiros (Spyros) on Sep 20, 2026, 09:08 PM
Very clean work and a beautiful airplane! Bravo
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: SP250 on Sep 21, 2026, 01:10 PM
Quote from: dputt7 on Sep 14, 2026, 09:03 AMThat's a very pretty aircraft to model, hope all goes well.
Saves people complaining when Lurk or I build a Lacey M10!  8)
John M
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: dputt7 on Sep 21, 2026, 04:56 PM
Surely vou can't compare the appeal of the BD4 to the offence of the Lacey  :o
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: TheLurker on Sep 21, 2026, 06:42 PM
Quote from: dputt7 on Sep 21, 2026, 04:56 PMSurely vou can't compare the appeal of the BD4 to the offence of the Lacey  :o
How dare you sir!  Tiddlywinks at dawn and my seconds will wait on yours at their convenience.

Back on topic, the BD4 is coming together very nicely indeed.
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Sep 21, 2026, 09:51 PM
Thank you all for your kind comments and encouragement. I really appreciate it!  :)
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Pete Fardell on Sep 22, 2026, 09:44 AM
Looking really nice. Quite tempting to build a big one. And yes, a very pretty little plane. (No one's seriously suggesting Laceys are in the same attractiveness league are they? Unless they're blind maybe...)
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: SP250 on Sep 22, 2026, 11:15 AM
Quote from: Pete Fardell on Sep 22, 2026, 09:44 AMLooking really nice. Quite tempting to build a big one. And yes, a very pretty little plane. (No one's seriously suggesting Laceys are in the same attractiveness league are they? Unless they're blind maybe...)
Well I am -6 and -7 diopters for my glasses prescription. So maybe that's the reason Pete, or could it be just to build one because it winds so many people up!  An engineers function over form, verses an artists visual attraction to the subject. 8)
John M
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Nigel_M on Sep 22, 2026, 07:35 PM
That's a very pretty aeroplane but in what part of the flight envelope does it need 'that' much tailplane/elevator movement? Is it massively aerobatic, like an Extra or CAP etc? Apologies, I'm not familiar with the full size.
Ta
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: pb_guy on Sep 23, 2026, 04:17 AM
I have flown in a BD-4. It seemed quite cramped with two men of normal size and weight in the front. The landing speed seemed quite high, about 80 knots, as compared to my usual Cessna 172 landings at 65 knots. Some other pilots called it a 'twitchy' airplane. But that has no relation to the model, which is quite nice. Lots of colour schemes available.
ian
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Pete Fardell on Sep 23, 2026, 01:03 PM
Quote from: SP250 on Sep 22, 2026, 11:15 AM...could it be just to build one because it winds so many people up!  An engineers function over form, verses an artists visual attraction to the subject. 8)
John M
I admit I do rather enjoy rising to the Lacey bait, and generally speaking I like functional 'ugly' aircraft.

Unlike the Lacey though the BD-4 has that slight nod to form though that make it functional AND good looking, like a Land Rover, Auster Agricola or Wittman Tailwind.
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Prosper on Sep 23, 2026, 07:45 PM
Quote from: Nigel_M. . .but in what part of the flight envelope does it need 'that' much tailplane/elevator movement?
Hi Nigel, that deflection looks much like (from memory) the up-travel of a Piper 'stabilator' as on Cherokee or Seneca etc. I just looked online - the PA28 has 18° up, but only 2deg down. The BD-4 looks as if it might have a shorter tail moment than the PA28, too.

Neat build, Markus, I'm following.

Stephen.
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: OZPAF on Sep 24, 2026, 04:20 AM
QuoteThat's a very pretty aeroplane but in what part of the flight envelope does it need 'that' much tailplane/elevator movement?

All flying stabilators could not  be expected to be as powerful as those with elevators - due to the camber changing capabilities of the elevator combined with the change in AOA.

Thus all flying stabs need larger angular displacement. However they do have the advantage of  easy adjustments to the decalage.

John
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Nigel_M on Sep 24, 2026, 04:40 PM
Thanks Stephen, John, that's directly contrary to my expectations of an all-flying tailplane. Based on large model gliders and the, I guess fairly old jet I crawled all over at university in the 1970's and '80's, a Hunter, the range of movement on those was minimal that I remember, although that may have been only the trim tab come to think of it. I had previously assumed the all-moving surface would be far more powerful across all types, so thanks for the update.
Digression ends  :)
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: g_kandylakis on Sep 24, 2026, 07:22 PM
Hopefully we will return to the BD4 of Markus now...

As a help to that or perhaps a reason for more discussion... might explain the need for so much up elevator ;D

Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Spiros (Spyros) on Sep 24, 2026, 07:58 PM
 ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D

I have lowered it, no worries..... ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Sep 24, 2026, 09:23 PM
Thanks, George, for sharing the video. Great model, Spiros! I hope to continue building tomorrow. Any tips are always appreciated.
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Sep 27, 2026, 06:59 PM
Here's my latest building progress update.

The nose has now been sanded to shape, and the adjustable fixture is finished.

In parallel, I tried to make a silicone mold from my resin-printed pilot figure in order to create a lightweight PU foam version. Unfortunately, that attempt was not successful. So I'll have to print a new set of figures and make another try at molding them. This time, I plan to dust the resin figure with talcum powder before making the mold, which should hopefully improve the result.

The next major step will be continuing with the fuselage. The side panels are already prepared and waiting. I have only limited experience with box fuselages, so I have a healthy respect for this next stage of the build.

Looking forward to making some more progress soon!

Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: RolandD6 on Sep 28, 2026, 02:50 AM
Quote from: MockwingF on Sep 27, 2026, 06:59 PM... I plan to dust the resin figure with talcum powder before making the mold, which should hopefully improve the result.
...

I suggest you try petroleum jelly thinned with white spirit but try it first on a scrap 3D print to ensure the print is not damaged. I used petroleum jelly a lot in past years but my patterns were not 3D prints. They were made from aluminium, steel or acetal plastic.

Wash the parting agent off the 3D print before painting.

It is/was possible to purchase a paintable! Silicon based parting agent in an aerosol can. I have some but never used it because the method described above worked for me and is safer for my lungs.

Paul
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: nickhawk on Sep 28, 2026, 04:13 PM
George Spyros since I watched the model flying last November in Nijmegen I decided to build one myself after I finish the projects I already started....You two have one each already so I cannot stay out of the game myself.. 
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Sep 30, 2026, 09:49 PM
The next attempt to make a mold from my resin-printed pilot was successful.

I reworked the figures once more, filling and minimizing recesses and cavities that had caused problems before. In addition, I coated the resin masters with a mixture of talcum powder and isopropyl alcohol, let it dry, blew off the excess, and then gently brushed the surface.

My first casting trial was done with 2-part PU foam. The mixing ratio still needs some adjustment, as the result is a bit too brittle. However, the level of detail is very good and all the fine features were reproduced nicely.

Tomorrow I will make another casting attempt and see if I can improve the foam mixture.

Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Sep 30, 2026, 09:58 PM
In parallel, I built my own small vacuum-forming box. It is not particularly pretty, but it works well enough.

My first tests were done with 0.50 mm PS sheet, but it was too thick and did not capture the contours well enough. Today I switched to 0.27 mm PP sheet, and the results are much better.

Tomorrow I will continue testing and will also try white 0.27 mm PP sheet. Based on my previous experience, the white material is usually a little heavier than the gray version, but it should be easier to paint. Since the wheel fairings need to be white anyway, that could be an advantage. The white sheet is also slightly softer, as it is made from post-consumer recycled material.

PP is not exactly a lightweight material, though. The four wheel fairing parts will probably end up at around 500 mg in total, so I will have to see if that is acceptable for the model. For now, I am very pleased with the quality of the formed parts.

Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Stunthenk on Oct 01, 2026, 11:40 AM
Quote from: g_kandylakis on Sep 24, 2026, 07:22 PMHopefully we will return to the BD4 of Markus now...

As a help to that or perhaps a reason for more discussion... might explain the need for so much up elevator ;D

A nice thing of this video is the exited voices of kids who are seeing this sort of flying for the first time. When the model hit the ceiling beam one said Ow! But another said No, its built to stand this!
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Spiros (Spyros) on Oct 01, 2026, 11:50 AM
......true....... ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D  ;D
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: g_kandylakis on Oct 01, 2026, 02:20 PM
Quote from: Stunthenk on Oct 01, 2026, 11:40 AMA nice thing of this video is the exited voices of kids who are seeing this sort of flying for the first time.

Henk, everyone was seeing this sort of flying for the first time, not just the kids.
Pete's spontaneous "bloody hell" says it all  ;D

George
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Oct 05, 2026, 11:46 AM
Hi everyone,
Small update on my progress!
The vacuum-formed wheel pants out of polypropylene film worked out really well. Each half comes in at around 65 mg.
The pilot figures made from 2-component polyurethane foam also turned out great. They are already primed in white and still need to be trimmed to final size. I estimate they will weigh around 250 mg fully painted.
I do have a question regarding the landing gear on the BD-4. I've attached the pictures showing how Bill Hannan suggests building it in his plans. Does this specific construction really make sense, and how is it precisely intended to work?
Spiros, George, did you implement this design on your models, or did you go with a different approach? I'd also love to hear from anyone else who has built this model—how did you solve this?
Thanks a lot in advance!
By the way, I've also started putting together the box fuselage using the two side pieces.
Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: g_kandylakis on Oct 05, 2026, 12:49 PM
Hi Markus,

LG exactly per plan. Works fine, light and strong enough but mainly springly enough. No worries

Nice looking pilot! As expected...

George
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Oct 05, 2026, 03:29 PM
Hi George,

thank you very much for the quick reply. In that case, I will build the landing gear mount exactly as shown on the plan.

Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Oct 06, 2026, 09:35 PM
Build Update: Box Fuselage & Cowling
�Today's session went really well, and I managed to finish the box fuselage structure smoothly.
�Tomorrow, I'll be moving on to the cowling section (right in front of the cockpit). That's going to be an interesting challenge: I'll be trying to shape the side curves using carefully sanded, ultra-thin 0.4 mm balsa.
Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Oct 07, 2026, 09:44 PM
Hi everyone,
Just a quick progress update on my current build: the fuselage is essentially finished and is now waiting to be covered!
Before I get started with the actual covering, I need to run a test on a scrap frame. I want to try airbrushing the Japan paper white before applying it, and I want to see how it reacts.
Along the way, a few questions came up. I would really appreciate your advice and tips on these points:
 * Window Film: Should I glue the window film to the sides and front from the outside before covering with paper, or after the paper covering is done?
 * Wing Covering (Bottom): Should I cover the bottom of the wings completely, or should I leave the cabin area open on the underside?
 * Winglets / Solid Balsa Parts: Should I also cover solid balsa parts like the winglets with paper, or is it better to leave the bare balsa and just give it a thin coat of dope/clear finish?
Looking forward to your thoughts and tips! Thanks a lot in advance!
Best,
Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: TheLurker on Oct 07, 2026, 10:05 PM
Quote* Window Film: Should I glue the window film to the sides and front from the outside before covering with paper, or after the paper covering is done?
Whichever suits you best and that you think will let you make the neatest job.  I usually fit glazing after covering because I find it easiest to do that.  If you leave the top of the cabin area uncovered it may, depending upon the size of the opening, be possible to fit the glazing on the inside of the fuselage after you've covered the sides and front of the fuselage and opened out the window frames.

Quote* Wing Covering (Bottom): Should I cover the bottom of the wings completely, or should I leave the cabin area open on the underside?
I'd cover the entire underside.  When the tissue is shrunk it makes a significant contribution to the rigidity & strength of the wing so leaving an area uncovered may impair that.

Quote* Winglets / Solid Balsa Parts: Should I also cover solid balsa parts like the winglets with paper, or is it better to leave the bare balsa and just give it a thin coat of dope/clear finish?
Depends. My preference is to cover sheet / solid parts with the same tissue as the rest of the airframe. I think it gives a more uniform look.  However... if you prefer the appearance of bare wood doped then do that.  Your model, your rules.
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Stunthenk on Oct 08, 2026, 11:02 AM
I prefer to add the windows first and then the tissue; but this requires some accurate tissue cutting and positioning. However, to me it looks more realistic. In the second picture the tissue is under the paper template and both are cut in the same operation. The tissue is then glued to the plastic sheeting and the sheeting is cut to the size of the tissue.
IMG_5149.JPG
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Stunthenk on Oct 08, 2026, 11:07 AM
And here is the second picture...IMG_5153.JPG
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: g_kandylakis on Oct 08, 2026, 04:44 PM
Hi Markus,

I see in the picture that you added the window frames made of balsa.
You could / can avoid this by using tissue for frame outline.

Windows material before or after covering?
As Henk said before it is better and more correct. After is easier but does not look good.

Bottom center section covering, yes. For a variety of reasons. Lurk +1

Wingtips. Cover them. Even with double curvature which will make covering difficult, the appearance will be much better than with dope. More uniform. Lurk +1

I like the cowl side openings. Never seen in a peanut before...

George
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Oct 08, 2026, 06:32 PM
Thanks for the quick and excellent tips!
 I'm now going to try several of your suggestions: applying the window film before covering, covering the balsa parts with Japanese tissue, and covering the lower center section of the wing. That's my next task.

I had already made the window frames from very thin balsa strips, which took quite a bit of effort. My original idea was to glue the clear film to them from the inside, but I couldn't make it work. Since the frames were already installed, I left them in place. Looking back, I probably should have asked about window techniques earlier. I'm learning!

The canopy opening is only on the left side, which is a distinctive feature of the full-size aircraft I'm modeling.

One more question: the real aircraft has a window in the wing that allows a view into the cockpit. It would show off the pilot figure quite nicely. My current plan is to cut the opening in the tissue before covering and glue the clear film directly to the underside of the tissue before attaching it to the wing, and to do the same on the underside of the wing.

I'd be very interested to hear your thoughts and any tips on this approach.

I'm happy to hear that you like it.

Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Stunthenk on Oct 08, 2026, 06:57 PM
On the FK.43 wing I made a balsa frame, covered it with plastic sheet only on the top and then covered the wing with tissue. The frame is full depth to attach the tissue covering on the bottom of the wing to it. Attaching the plastic sheet directly to the tissue should work, but be aware of wrinkles!
IMG_5135.JPGIMG_5228.JPG
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Oct 08, 2026, 09:31 PM
Hello Stunthenk,
 your skylight solution seems to be the best option for the BD-4 as well. It only requires a few balsa strips, so the additional weight should be minimal. I'll try to build something along those lines and see how it turns out. Thanks for the idea!
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Stunthenk on Oct 08, 2026, 10:45 PM
Good luck! I was wondering about how attaching plastic sheet to tissue would work out, but we've avoided that question, haven't we?
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Jmk89 on Oct 09, 2026, 02:37 AM
If you use laminating film or some other Mylar film to cover the centre section, you can keep the covering strength and keep the transparency. Best of both worlds....
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Oct 10, 2026, 09:31 AM
Hi Jeremy,

That's a good idea as well. At the moment I'm experimenting with airbrushing dyes onto my 12 g/m² Japico tissue while it's mounted in a covering frame, following the tips from Maxflyart's Free Flight Basics tutorial on YouTube.

My next step will be covering a test frame to see how the tissue reacts during the actual covering process. I'll also try the Mylar/tissue combination. However, based on my previous experiences with Mylar-covered models, I have a healthy respect for that method.

Still, I think it's a very good suggestion, and I'll definitely give it a try.

Thanks for the idea!

Best regards, Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Oct 19, 2026, 09:09 PM
Quote from: Stunthenk on Oct 08, 2026, 11:02 AMI prefer to add the windows first and then the tissue; but this requires some accurate tissue cutting and positioning. However, to me it looks more realistic. In the second picture the tissue is under the paper template and both are cut in the same operation. The tissue is then glued to the plastic sheeting and the sheeting is cut to the size of the tissue.
IMG_5149.JPG

Hello Henk, and of course everyone else,

I still have some questions about the window area. What do you use to glue the clear film to the paper window frames?

I already had some difficulties during my test pieces, but now, with my first attempt at the side windows, I seem to have reached my limits.

My procedure is as follows: first, I cut the window openings from the Japanese tissue using the template. The next step should be to glue the clear film to the back side of this paper frame. Unfortunately, this is where I run into problems.

If I apply the glue to the tissue, it soaks through the paper and sticks everything to the paper template underneath. If I place the film on a separate template and brush the glue onto the film, it is either too thick and cannot be applied evenly, or it is too thin and the tissue does not stick properly.

I am using UHU Por thinned with acetone. I was not able to thin UHU Por with lighter fluid.

Do you have any suggestions, tricks, or perhaps a completely different method that works better?

Thanks in advance!

Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Stunthenk on Oct 19, 2026, 11:15 PM
What I do is glue the window plastic (I use Evergreen Clear sheet 0,13 mm, item no 9005 J-1) to the fuselage side using either foam friendly CA applied with a pin or nitrate dope applied with a small brush, depending on the structure. I then cover the fuselage sides with the accurately prepared tissue. Finally I stick down the tissue that is framing the windows with some more dope applied with a small brush. This way the plastic windows from the view of the tissue are only a piece of the fuselage side, and not a different item to be glued seperately.
Of course, this the easy method for flat side windows; those with a curvature, or even a double curvature ae an entirely different kettle of fish!
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Oct 20, 2026, 10:15 AM
Hi Henk,
Thank you. I will adjust my building process and test the materials.

Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Nov 08, 2026, 07:28 AM
Unfortunately, progress has been rather slow recently. Last week I lost quite a bit of time due to a major repair on my Sainte Formule model. During rubber winding, an inattentive RC flyer walked into the fully stretched motor, and the model suffered two fuselage breaks. The wing also required repairs and complete re-covering.

The good news is that yesterday's trimming session was successful, so I am feeling optimistic again.

As for the BD-4, the propeller has been designed and built. The final fine-tuning will be done once the wheels are installed. The wheels are currently under construction and are being cast from 2K PU foam using moulds made from air-drying modelling clay. The masters for the moulds were resin-printed wheel halves.

The coloured side stripes and the registration markings are also in progress.

Hopefully I'll have more progress to report soon!

Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Stunthenk on Nov 08, 2026, 11:05 PM
Wicked looking prop! I know next to nothing about props for peanut or somewhat larger rubber  models. Would like some tips, formula or explanation on prop diameter, blade area and pitch versus rubber length / thickness for different sizes of models. Anything to improve on the standard commercial  plastic props.
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Piecost on Nov 09, 2026, 12:51 AM
Good to see progress on this nice model. I look forward to reports of it flying and am sure that it will fly well.

Stunthenk,

It is worth getting hold of a.second hand copy of the out of print book:

Making Scale Model Airplanes Fly
William F. McCombs

It is basically and engineering textbook for scale model aeroplanes. But, it has very small type written text and lots of graphs, so is not for everyone.
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: SP250 on Nov 09, 2026, 11:07 AM
Doug Hunt had the McCombs book reprinted for SAM 35 I think - may have some left in stock.

John M
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Jmk89 on Nov 09, 2026, 12:17 PM
I have an electronic version of McCombs book which I downloaded from somewhere

I will arrange for it to be uploaded to the HPA Plans Gallery in the next day or so.
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Nov 09, 2026, 10:04 PM
For my BD-4 Peanut (330 mm wingspan, approximately max. 9 g flying weight including rubber motor), the propeller design was driven by two major constraints.

First, the desired ground clearance with the model sitting level on its landing gear limits the maximum practical propeller diameter to approximately 114 mm.

Second, the relatively wide nose block required a much slimmer blade root section so that the blades could clear the fuselage during rotation. This resulted in a long, narrow transition toward the hub compared to what would normally be chosen purely for aerodynamic reasons.

The final blade outline is a compromise between a classic Antoinette and a Langley propeller shape, aiming to combine sufficient climb performance with a long motor run.

Key Dimensions
Propeller diameter: 114 mm
Radius: 57 mm
Blade length: 40 mm
Maximum blade width: 20 mm
Root width: 5 mm
Maximum width located at approximately 75% of blade length
Target pitch: approximately 150 mm

The limitation to 20 mm maximum blade width was also a compromise.

The blades were cut from 1.0 mm quarter-grain balsa and sanded down to approximately 0.6–0.7 mm thickness before forming. The low weight and dimensional stability of quarter-grain balsa were considered more important than pursuing a perfectly optimized blade outline.

After the blades had been glued to the propeller shaft assembly, the most vulnerable areas, particularly around the blade roots and blade tips, were reinforced with lightweight Japanese tissue. The tissue was applied using a heavily thinned mixture of UHU Hart and acetone, creating an extremely light reinforcement while significantly improving durability.

The propeller shaft tube was made from rolled covering tissue wrapped around a 2 mm drill shank and bonded with the same UHU Hart/acetone mixture.

Pitch Calculation

Pitch was estimated using the standard propeller equation:

Pitch = 2 × π × Radius × tan(Blade Angle)

where:

Pitch = propeller pitch
Radius = measurement radius
Blade Angle = local blade angle at that radius

Using a 45° pitch gauge:

tan(45°) = 1

the equation simplifies to:

Radius = Pitch / (2 × π)

For a target pitch of 150 mm:

Radius = 150 / (2 × 3.1416) = 23.9 mm

Therefore, a blade angle of 45° measured at approximately 24 mm radius from the propeller center corresponds to a pitch of roughly 150 mm.

Forming Jig

The blades are pre-formed using a cylinder with a diameter of 40 mm.

The forming jig used for the propeller blades was inspired by a sketch by Dr. Heinrich Eder published in Saalflug mit Leichtmodellen. The publication was used as a reference for the blade-forming process and also provides valuable background information on propeller geometry, pitch, efficiency, and practical construction techniques for indoor free-flight models.

The required blade alignment angle on the cylinder was derived geometrically from the target propeller pitch. For this design, the theoretical value is approximately 31° relative to the cylinder axis.

The complete derivation of the formula used for this calculation will be presented separately at a later stage.

For practical workshop use, a 30° reference line can be used on the forming cylinder. The difference between the calculated 31° and the practical 30° setup is negligible when compared with the variations introduced by wood properties, moisture content, sanding, gluing, and final trimming of the propeller.

Forming Process
Cut the blade from quarter-grain balsa.
Sand the blade to approximately 0.6–0.7 mm thickness.
Moisten the blade.
Place the blade on a 40 mm diameter cylinder.
Align the blade axis approximately 30° to the cylinder axis.
Allow the blade to dry completely.
Glue the blades to the shaft assembly.
Reinforce the root and tip areas with Japanese tissue and a thinned UHU Hart/acetone mixture.
Verify the final pitch during assembly using the 45° gauge.
Notes

Many of the design parameters are not the result of pure calculation. The final configuration evolved through a combination of geometric analysis, established propeller theory,  free-flight experience, discussions with other modelers, and informed estimation.
Now I just hope it flies as well as it looks on the building board
Markus
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Jmk89 on Nov 10, 2026, 04:12 AM
Looking at my copy of McCombs book, I downloaded it from the HPA 2 Plans Gallery.  So I think that it is appropriate for it to be on the HPA 3 Plans Gallery too!

The book has been uploaded and will be available once George has sprinkled magic dust over it!
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: g_kandylakis on Nov 10, 2026, 07:44 AM
https://hpa.aeromodelling.gr/plans/details.php?image_id=2213
Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: MockwingF on Nov 17, 2026, 08:54 AM

I still owe you the final photos and a short report.
In the end, I finished last in the Peanut Scale class at IIFI 2026, but I am quite proud of my static score. After all, the BD-4 was my very first Peanut Scale model, and I learned an incredible amount throughout the entire building process. I already have my next project in mind.
With a flight time of 24 seconds plus 10 seconds ROG, I was still well below the potential of the model, according to the experienced flyers. At IIFI, I received a lot of constructive advice, especially regarding my propeller. I plan to rework it and continue trimming and optimizing the model over the coming weekends in our local hall. Let's see how far I can take it.
Considering that the model was only completed on Thursday evening and that I was able to start trimming no earlier than Saturday, it already flies remarkably well. It performs beautiful right-hand circles, takes off cleanly from the floor, and lands just as smoothly.
Now it's time for one thing above all: practice, practice, practice!
Many thanks to everyone who supported me with advice, tips, and encouragement. Without the help of the Peanut Scale community, this first model certainly would not have been as successful as it was
Markus

Title: Re: My First Peanut Scale Build: BD-4 by Bill Hannan
Post by: Piecost on Nov 17, 2026, 08:22 PM
Lovely model!