Welcome to HPA. Please login or sign up.

Members
  • Total Members: 376
  • Latest: Andrew
Stats
  • Total Posts: 6,885
  • Total Topics: 481
  • Online today: 68
  • Online ever: 484 (Oct 19, 2026, 11:51 AM)
Users Online

Recent topics

1960s Coupe d’hiver postal comp

Started by Jmk89, Dec 28, 2025, 11:39 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Red Buzzard

Hello Everyone,

We're (four members of the Willamette Modelers including two two-time winners and a three time winner of this event - and several other placings) are just back from a 1500 mile round trip to a "local" contest. These issues, mylar and dates, were discussed for several of those miles. I think the consensus was that dropping "mylar" is a simple solution to that question. As to dates, it seems some statement such as "...models known to have been flown before Dec. 31, 1960..." would capture the 1960s cut-off and allow models such as the Lenderman, or other designs that we may not even know existed but did fly in comps of the era. In the case of the Lenderman, one of the gentlemen who timed several of Lenderman's record flights was on the trip with us and knows to the day when the record flight occured. That change might prompt others to drag out something from the shed and enter it. We all enjoy this event and should be encouraging others to come out and fly rather than be too dogmatic about constraints.

We're all experienced gentlemen bent on enjoying an outing, each other's company, and the joy of flying...even in an unlikely season. Finding a nice day during that season makes it all the more enjoyable. Wind it tight, pick some air and laugh when it works.

Bill Swift

billdennis747

I still say leave it as it is, but nobody else seems to have objected. I wonder what Mark thinks.

Jmk89

Hi Bill

Thanks for posting the results of your discussion.

As someone who has drafted rules for many years, may I make some suggestions?

First, I agree that the rules themselves can be changed in the way you suggest but I would put a couple of notes to  explain the scope of the rules. So one note might  say that Kevlar, carbon fibre and similar are not allowed but Mylar under tissue is permitted.  Similarly, I think that a note giving some guidance on what is needed to show that the original model was flown before the deadline. Obviously a plan published before the deadline would work. But something fairly definite is needed to show that the model was flown in the form presented before the deadline - examples would be photos in pre-deadline magazines, a private plan dated by the designer, a magazine article whenever published that establishes that the design was flown before the deadline.

Second, I would express the deadline as 'before 1 January 1970'. That makes it clear that 31 December 1969 is permitted.

I also think that an entrant who wants to clarify whether a design or a material complies should be invited to obtain a ruling from the organiser at least 4 weeks before they propose to fly giving the organiser all relevant information available to the entrant. After a ruling is given, it should be generally available, so all potential entrants know how the rules are being applied.
All the best
Jeremy

Better drowned than duffers, if not duffers won't drown

dputt7

  I tried to stay out of this but from my experience when the event was proposed the main rule that explained what the comp. is about was any model published during the decade of the Sixties was eligible. That cut out any if's or maybe's. I was able to fly my 50's Coupe Ailbass because it was published in the Sixties.  I would not mind if Jeremy was allowed to fly his coupe but there would have to be a rule change