Welcome to HPA. Please login or sign up.

Members
  • Total Members: 376
  • Latest: Andrew
Stats
  • Total Posts: 6,862
  • Total Topics: 481
  • Online today: 55
  • Online ever: 484 (Oct 19, 2026, 11:51 AM)
Users Online

Recent topics

1960s Coupe d’hiver postal comp

Started by Jmk89, Dec 28, 2025, 11:39 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

PeeTee

Hello Sean, it's good to hear from you again.

Peter

Mike Thomas

Yes Sean, as Dave says, it's nice to hear from you.

"I find 10 stands of 3mm gives a snappy climb and about a 50sec run, but it does need to be fully wound; 12 strands is more relaxed to wind."

An interesting observation about the practicalities. I agree. Mike.

G GRELL

Hi All
We are about 3weeks away from the start of the coupe postal in the Northern Hemisphere hope everyone is ready. I have mailed the awards out and they should be arriving soon. There has been some talk here in Oregon to move the eligibility date from December 31 1969 to December 31 1970 the reason behind this that a local rubber flyer by the name of John Lenderman set a National record with his coupe in the mid 1960's on a near perfect day in February but the plan was not published until March of 1970. Please let us know your feelings on this topic. Once again thank you for everyone that participated last year and this year bring a friend.
Glenn

Jmk89

Glenn

For what it is worth, my view is that if the plan is put forward as being of a plane that flew before 31 December 1969 then it really doesn't matter when it found its way into a magazine. 

Let's say that someone has an actual model that we know flew before 31 December 1969 (eg the Monts Chicken Coop) and someone with access to that original model prepares a plan of it, it should not matter that the plan was only published in 2026 - the model is a pre-1970 model.

However, if the plan is of a plane that started with earlier models that flew before 1970 but is an updated version to a date after 1969, then the plan is not a proper basis for the model to be pre-1970.

Alternatively, if other material (eg an accompanying article, photos taken before the cut off date) makes it clear what changes were made between the pre-1970 version and the more recent version shown in the plan, and the model is made reversing those changes and so it is consistent with the pre-1970 version of the model, then that version falls within the pre-1970 rule.

On that basis I would say that John Lenderman's model would likely comply, unless it is clear that it wasn't built until after 31 December 1969 or unless changes were made to a pre-1970 model which were not reversed.

What gets interesting is something like George Perryman's Mugwump - it won the 1970 King Orange Internats and the 1972 US Nats and the plan was published in MAN August 1973.  If there is evidence that George flew it before 1 January 1970, then it complies, if not, not.
All the best
Jeremy

Better drowned than duffers, if not duffers won't drown

billdennis747


billdennis747

I draw your attention to rule 2 ('published' refers to a plan, not some photos)  and rule 5 (no mylar). If you are all going down this route, the rules need changing.


Mike Thomas

#96
Bill, I know that Mylar/Melinex was invented and became commercially available in the mid 50's. What I don't know, is when and who the first person was to use tissue over Mylar for covering; but I believe it wasn't until the 70's. I would like to know, for the purposes of the 60's Coupe Postal, is what should prevail to determine the rules.

i.e. should it be legal because Mylar was readily available in the '60's. Or should it be legal only if it was actually used in the 60's.  I don't think tissue over Mylar improves the flying of the model, only the durability of the covering. Mike.

billdennis747

Hello Mike. I don't recall tissue/mylar until the late 70s at the earliest. Personally it wouldn't bother me if it was allowed here but the rule needs adjusting. As long as the outline and basic structure are unchanged it's fine by me. Similarly the change to the DT rule was common sense. However we seem to be nudging at the 'publication date' to accommodate a specific model.
There are many dozens of published plans to choose from and none of them is 'the one'.

Jmk89

In the May 1970 report of the CdH international in AeroModeller, JOD mentioned a model covered with tissue and Melinex - with the Melinex on top of the tissue, it is also suggested in the June 1969 article on plastic covering.

In any event, I agree with Bill that the issue is to update the words of the rules to make them conform with what is now being considered to comply with the intended operation of the rules.
All the best
Jeremy

Better drowned than duffers, if not duffers won't drown

cvasec

I remember that some years ago in a similar debate, somebody said "As long as today's air flows over yesterday's material...."
Ron

billdennis747

Quote from: Jmk89 on Nov 11, 2026, 11:12 AMIn the May 1970 report of the CdH international in AeroModeller, JOD mentioned a model covered with tissue and Melinex - with the Melinex on top of the tissue, it is also suggested in the June 1969 article on plastic covering.

Melinex over undoped Modelspan! Clearly a very early development - how on earth did he do that?
I think the bottom line is nobody really cares. I do this for reasons of nostalgia only. Just remove the reference to mylar.

Mike Thomas

Hello Bill,
               "I do this for reasons of nostalgia only"

I really identify with this sentiment. Ultimately, it is, for most of us, I suspect, the reason for our participation in the 60's Coupe Postal; and so we want the model to be authentically 60's, just how we would have built it, had we built it, say, in 1965. And this is true for any vintage model. I am about to build a Walthew Rubber Model, a model I built as a kid in the early 50's. I have a great attachment to it in memory, largely because it flew well, and was the first model I lost in lift. I am going to build it as I did then, no changes at all. And if I lose it in lift, well, it's just history repeating itself. Mike.

Jmk89

#102
Quote from: Mike Thomas on Nov 12, 2026, 03:08 AMHello Bill,
              "I do this for reasons of nostalgia only"

I really identify with this sentiment. Ultimately, it is, for most of us, I suspect, the reason for our participation in the 60's Coupe Postal; and so we want the model to be authentically 60's, just how we would have built it, had we built it, say, in 1965. And this is true for any vintage model. I am about to build a Walthew Rubber Model, a model I built as a kid in the early 50's. I have a great attachment to it in memory, largely because it flew well, and was the first model I lost in lift. I am going to build it as I did then, no changes at all. And if I lose it in lift, well, it's just history repeating itself. Mike.

Hi Mike

Does that mean that you will only use balsa cement and sew all the wire bits and smear them with balsa cement to attach them to wood bits?

I agree with the sentiment that the model should be "authentic" and not use carbon fibre, kevlar, boron, titanium or other 'unobtainium', but I don't think that, for example, using CA or epoxy makes it "unauthentic".  Similarly, if you cover it with EZE tissue and use EZE dope, I think it's still "authentic".

But if you want, to please yourself, to make it as you would have in 1965 using only the glues and other materials you could obtain then, well, I tips me lid to you.  It reminds me of the woodworkers who work at places like Colonial Williamsburg in the US who only use tools from the 18th century, dress up in period costume and use hot hide glue.  I appreciate their dedication and the performance they give for the visiting public, but I don't think that it makes the replica furniture they make any more "authentic" than if they used a power saw and aliphatic resin glue.

I think that the "test" on authenticity is the aerodynamics of the model.  If you don't affect that, then use of a material or technique is Okay.  So you have to use the same airfoils and spars, the same dimensions for the pieces and you can't reinforce parts of the structure with modern materials.  I also think that it probably isn't "authentic" if you use a folding prop if the original had a freewheeler.  However, I can see a 12 year old Jeremy doing that....And I would put a D/T on it (and I would have when I was 12 if Fantastic Toys and Hobbies or Hobbyco had any D/T Fuse).

But this is a matter on which rational minds may reasonably differ.  Which is why I asked for a ruling from Glenn on tissue over mylar - I hate post-competition arguments on whether the model complies with the rules.  If the ruling had gone the other way, I would not have used mylar under the tissue and hoped that the model survived  landing on a bush, fence, stalk or car aerial ( the last happened to one of my models in 1974 or 5 - no photo because in those days I was a poor, high school student who delivered supermarket flyers to get $2.00 pocket money, only had an Instamatic camera and film and processing costs meant that I only took "good" pictures).
All the best
Jeremy

Better drowned than duffers, if not duffers won't drown

Mike Thomas

#103
"Does that mean that you will only use balsa cement and sew all the wire bits and smear them with balsa cement to attach them to wood bits?"

Yes Jeremy that is exactly what I would do if I were building a model purely out of nostalgia for my childhood aeromodelling. What joy there was in peeling dried balsa cement off my fingertips after a building session. And, you can still get balsa cement, and for some jobs, it's still the best glue for the job.
As for period costume, unfortunately I no longer fit into my primary school uniform, and if I did, I'd look a little bit silly.

billdennis747

When I said 'I don't care', what I should have said was 'I don't mind', and I doubt anybody else does either. 'Please yourself' is my rule. None of it makes any difference as long as the outlines, airfoils, propellor etc are the same. The days of getting into rows because J O'D put a turbulator on his Scram are gone.
This subject only got my interest because of the suggestion surrounding qualifying dates and publication, but that hasn't been mentioned!
My Baron and Garter Knights are ready to go this year.
Bill