Welcome to HPA. Please login or sign up.

Members
  • Total Members: 376
  • Latest: Andrew
Stats
  • Total Posts: 6,864
  • Total Topics: 481
  • Online today: 55
  • Online ever: 484 (Oct 19, 2026, 11:51 AM)
Users Online

Recent topics

Short S.42 1912 monoplane

Started by Pete Fardell, Dec 28, 2025, 09:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Squirrelnet

If it's got faster could you remove a tiny bit of down thrust to improve the climb ??

Pete Fardell

Quote from: Squirrelnet on Oct 30, 2026, 08:36 PMIf it's got faster could you remove a tiny bit of down thrust to improve the climb ??
That's a good thought. Probably safer than messing with the CG.

Jmk89

I would check that the thinner motor has not moved the CG back a little anyway and so some nose weight could also be removed as well as some downthrust.

If you had a bit more time before IIFI, I would be tempted to use a lifting tail, a more rearward CG and remove more nose weight and downthrust.

However, in the circs, I would go to IIFI with the current structure and trim it as best you can.

BTW as JOD points out (Better ... p34ff) while the left turn is apparently 'natural' and 'simpler, the right turn is a better balance of the forces of a model under power and also has the advantage of not having a widening flight circle as the torque runs down.  If that is the case, then RH turn makes more sense for indoor flying of scale models (which fly faster than indoor duration models) because it retains a more consistent circle size and allows the modeller to use the maximum hall width for the entire flight.  John also pointed out that it is convenient when flying indoors for models to turn the same way (reduced chance of collision), so he made left handed props which reversed the torque reaction and allowed for a LH turn with the same balance of forces as you obtain with a RH prop and RH turn.' Plenty of food for thought here :)
All the best
Jeremy

Better drowned than duffers, if not duffers won't drown

Pete Fardell

#63
Thanks- all very good thoughts to consider there; I'll have fun trying to improve it next outdoor season.

For now though, I went with Chris's suggestion of just reducing the down-thrust and had another go in my field this afternoon. I did also try removing a few grams of noseweight but this, strangely, resulted in a steeper dive. It may have just been a poor launch but having escaped without damage I put the weight back on quickly before proceeding further! The only other change I made on the field was to cut away the top fuselage bracing threads in the bay where the motor peg is (which weren't really structural anyway). That's because I noticed the rubber was often getting tangled in them, leading to bunching and robbing me of some useful motor duration.

Anyway, with less downthust and a clearer motor run, I  managed a couple of flights closer to 20 seconds than 15 which is just what I need, so thanks for the suggestion, Chris.
It now seems to hold its turn better too, when wound up to near the max, which bodes better for indoors. It did drift downwind a bit, but hopefully it might still stay within the walls at the IIFI.
Here's a vid of the last flight before I called it a day. I probably won't fly it again till I get to Wijchen now. I'm off to the Norwind meeting at Rochdale tomorrow but that hall's a bit small for trimming this one in, so there I'll focus on the Jodel instead.

Jmk89

That's looking quite promising, Pete. Good luck in Holland
All the best
Jeremy

Better drowned than duffers, if not duffers won't drown

g_kandylakis

Looks much better and should be enough for IIFI. Indoors you need less power even with the take off.

I guess we'll know this time in 14 days...

George